Introduction Serotonin syndrome (SS) is a drug-induced constellation of various clinical features that result from excess central serotonergic tone. The clinical features range from barely perceptible to life-threatening conditions. Cases We describe four patients with acute headache (four days to three weeks) who were receiving serotonergic drugs for other indications. There was a temporal relation between the administration of the serotonergic drugs and the development of the headaches. All four patients fulfilled the Hunter Serotonin Toxicity Criteria for SS. In parallel, two patients fulfilled the Sternbach's criteria for SS. Discontinuation of the serotonergic drugs and the administration of cyprohepatadine led to complete improvement in three to seven days in all four patients. Discussion A review of the literature suggests that some overlaps exist in the pathophysiology between SS and headache disorders, including medication-overuse headache. The overlap is also in the management. The drugs found to be effective in SS (cyproheptadine, chlorpromazine, olanzapine, etc.) are also known to have positive effects on some headache disorders. Conclusion Physicians should consider the diagnosis of SS in patients with new onset or worsening headache after the addition of serotonergic drugs, especially in the presence of objective signs on examination suggestive of the disorder such as tremor, fever, hyperreflexia, diaphoresis or tachycardia.