On the Concept of Praecox Feeling

Despite the development and widespread diffusion of modern nosographic systems, the diagnosis of schizophrenia continues to raise several epistemological issues. To address these issues, a number of researchers are currently pursuing the possibility of an integration between reliable, objective approaches and the intersubjective perspective in the clinical encounter. In the present article, we discuss Rumke's popular concept of praecox feeling, as introduced in 1941 and re-elaborated over the following 20 years. Our aim was to thoroughly analyze the author's original formulation and to identify the connections between his thinking and certain psychopathological developments, epistemological issues, and research perspectives on schizophrenia. The praecox feeling is presented by Rumke as a sensitive diagnostic tool for schizophrenia that is rooted in the peculiar subjective experience of the clinician when encountering a schizophrenic patient. This experience seems to be characterized by two essential dimensions: a subjective one, which reflects the failure of a clinician's empathic effort due to a fundamental alteration of the intersubjective space, a phenomenon related to schizophrenic autism, and a gestaltic, objective one, which is grounded in the clinician's implicit typifying process as a consequence of collecting recurrent clinical observations over the course of his/her professional experience. According to Rumke, the diagnostic use of the praecox feeling should be limited to the acute phases of the schizophrenic process, as the clinician's experience of an intersubjective struggle is attenuated in interactions with older, chronic patients. The multifaceted nature of Rumke's proposal seems to have contributed to some theoretical critiques and to inconclusive results from empirical investigations, leading to a progressive devaluation of the scientific and diagnostic validity of praecox feeling. The present analysis of the original concept suggests that a renewed research interest in the role of the clinician's subjective experience with regard to the schizophrenic patient could be helpful. (c) 2018 S. Karger AG, Basel