Embryo loss and double effect

被引:6
|
作者
Di Nucci, Ezio [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Duisburg Essen, Inst Philosophie, D-45117 Essen, Germany
关键词
Stem Cell Research;
D O I
10.1136/medethics-2012-101172
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
I defend the argument that if embryo loss in stem cell research is morally problematic, then embryo loss in in vivo conception is similarly morally problematic. According to a recent challenge to this argument, we can distinguish between in vivo embryo loss and the in vitro embryo loss of stem cell research by appealing to the doctrine of double effect. I argue that this challenge fails to show that in vivo embryo loss is a mere unintended side effect while in vitro embryo loss is an intended means and that, even if we refine the challenge by appealing to Michael Bratman's three roles of intention, the distinction is still unwarranted.
引用
收藏
页码:537 / 540
页数:4
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Embryo deaths in reproduction and embryo research: a reply to Murphy's double effect argument
    Devolder, Katrien
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ETHICS, 2013, 39 (08) : 533 - 536
  • [2] Effect of blastomere loss on the outcome of frozen embryo replacement cycles
    El-Toukhy, T
    Khalaf, Y
    Al-Darazi, K
    Andritsos, V
    Taylor, A
    Braude, P
    [J]. FERTILITY AND STERILITY, 2003, 79 (05) : 1106 - 1111
  • [3] The effect of double vitrification on embryo reproductive potential and clinical outcome
    Oraiopoulou, C.
    Karagianni, M.
    Toumpa, O.
    Ioannidou, D.
    Papadopoulou, M.
    Christophoridis, N.
    Papatheodorou, A.
    Chatziparasidou, A.
    [J]. HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2022, 37
  • [4] EARLY EMBRYO LOSS
    MCLEAN, JM
    [J]. LANCET, 1987, 1 (8540): : 1033 - 1034
  • [5] RESEARCH ON EMBRYO LOSS
    不详
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EQUINE VETERINARY SCIENCE, 1993, 13 (06) : 326 - 327
  • [6] EFFECT OF RYE EMBRYO RIBOSOME NUCLEASE ON DOUBLE-STRANDED-RNA
    SIWECKA, MA
    RYTEL, M
    SZARKOWSKI, JW
    [J]. PHYTOCHEMISTRY, 1982, 21 (02) : 273 - 275
  • [7] The effect of hearing loss on identification of asynchronous double vowels
    Lentz, Jennifer J.
    Marsh, Shavon L.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF SPEECH LANGUAGE AND HEARING RESEARCH, 2006, 49 (06): : 1354 - 1367
  • [8] EMBRYO QUALITY INTERACTIONS IN DOUBLE EMBRYO TRANSFERS.
    Hartshorne, G.
    Crossman, R.
    Brosens, J.
    Stallard, N.
    [J]. FERTILITY AND STERILITY, 2013, 100 (03) : S293 - S293
  • [9] Embryo Loss and Moral Status
    Delaney, James
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2023, 48 (03): : 252 - 264
  • [10] THE EFFECT OF MATERNAL BMI ON EUPLOIDY AND EMBRYO MORPHOKINETICS IN RECURRENT PREGNANCY LOSS PATIENTS
    Colakoglu, Yesim Kumtepe
    Aygun, Tutku Melis
    Ozkara, Gulcin
    Yelke, Hakan Kadir
    Aygun, Melih
    Yildiz, Semra
    Irez, Tulay
    Kahraman, Semra
    [J]. FERTILITY AND STERILITY, 2023, 120 (04) : E241 - E241