What User Interface to Use for Virtual Reality? 2D, 3D or Speech-A User Study

被引:9
|
作者
Weiss, Yannick [1 ]
Hepperle, Daniel [2 ]
Siess, Andreas [2 ]
Woelfel, Matthias [2 ]
机构
[1] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Fac Math Informat & Stat, Munich, Germany
[2] Karlsruhe Univ Appl Sci, Fac Comp Sci & Business Informat Syst, Karlsruhe, Germany
关键词
virtual reality; comparison of user interfaces; input modality; 2D interface; 3D interface; speech interface;
D O I
10.1109/CW.2018.00021
中图分类号
TP301 [理论、方法];
学科分类号
081202 ;
摘要
In virtual reality different demands on the user interface have to be addressed than on classic screen applications. That's why established strategies from other digital media cannot be transferred unreflected and at least adaptation is required. So one of the leading questions is: which form of interface is preferable for virtual reality? Are 2D interfaces that are mostly used in combination with mouse or touch interactions the means of choice, although they do not use the medium's full capabilities? What about 3D interfaces that can be naturally integrated into the virtual space? And last but not least: are speech interfaces, the fastest and most natural form of human interaction/communication, which have recently established themselves in other areas (e.g. digital assistants), ready to conquer the world of virtual reality? To answer these question this work compares these three approaches based on a quantitative user study and highlights advantages and disadvantages of the respective interfaces for virtual reality applications.
引用
收藏
页码:50 / 57
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] 2D, 3D or speech? A case study on which user interface is preferable for what kind of object interaction in immersive virtual reality
    Hepperle, Daniel
    Weiss, Yannick
    Siess, Andreas
    Woelfel, Matthias
    [J]. COMPUTERS & GRAPHICS-UK, 2019, 82 : 321 - 331
  • [2] 3D User Interface in Virtual Reality
    Yue, Gu
    [J]. HCI INTERNATIONAL 2021 - LATE BREAKING POSTERS, HCII 2021, PT I, 2021, 1498 : 418 - 423
  • [3] 3D virtual reality vs. 2D desktop registration user interface comparison
    Bueckle, Andreas
    Buehling, Kilian
    Shih, Patrick C.
    Boerner, Katy
    [J]. PLOS ONE, 2021, 16 (10):
  • [4] A Comparative Study of 2D and 3D Mobile Keypad User Interaction Preferences in Virtual Reality Graphic User Interfaces.
    Kaur, Akriti
    Yammiyavar, Pradeep G.
    [J]. VRST'17: PROCEEDINGS OF THE 23RD ACM SYMPOSIUM ON VIRTUAL REALITY SOFTWARE AND TECHNOLOGY, 2017,
  • [5] A Hybrid 2D/3D User Interface for Radiological Diagnosis
    Veera Bhadra Harish Mandalika
    Alexander I. Chernoglazov
    Mark Billinghurst
    Christoph Bartneck
    Michael A. Hurrell
    Niels de Ruiter
    Anthony P. H. Butler
    Philip H. Butler
    [J]. Journal of Digital Imaging, 2018, 31 : 56 - 73
  • [6] A Hybrid 2D/3D User Interface for Radiological Diagnosis
    Mandalika, Veera Bhadra Harish
    Chernoglazov, Alexander I.
    Billinghurst, Mark
    Bartneck, Christoph
    Hurrell, Michael A.
    de Ruiter, Niels
    Butler, Anthony P. H.
    Butler, Philip H.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF DIGITAL IMAGING, 2018, 31 (01) : 56 - 73
  • [7] User Responses to a Humanoid Robot Observed in Real Life, Virtual Reality, 3D and 2D
    Mara, Martina
    Stein, Jan-Philipp
    Latoschik, Marc Erich
    Lugrin, Birgit
    Schreiner, Constanze
    Hostettler, Rafael
    Appel, Markus
    [J]. FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY, 2021, 12
  • [8] Comparative Study on 2D and 3D User Interface for Eliminating Cognitive Loads in Augmented Reality Repetitive Tasks
    Li, Xiangdong
    Zheng, Cindy
    Pan, Zhenghua
    Huang, Zhongnan
    Niu, Yuting
    Wang, Pengfei
    Geng, Weidong
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMAN-COMPUTER INTERACTION, 2023,
  • [9] Anatomical 2D/3D Shape-Matching in Virtual Reality: A User Interface for Quantifying Joint Kinematics with Radiographic Imaging
    Kim, Kyungyoon
    Lawrence, Rebekah L.
    Kyllonen, Nikki
    Ludewig, Paula M.
    Ellingson, Arin M.
    Keefe, Daniel F.
    [J]. 2017 IEEE SYMPOSIUM ON 3D USER INTERFACES (3DUI), 2017, : 243 - 244
  • [10] 3D virtual "smart home" user interface
    Borodulkin, L
    Ruser, H
    Tränkler, HR
    [J]. VIMS 2002: IEEE INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON VIRTUAL AND INTELLIGENT MEASUREMENT SYSTEMS: DISTRIBUTED INTELLIGENT SENSING FOR ADVANCED INTEGRATED VIRTUAL ENVIRONMENTS, 2002, : 111 - 115