Best non-contrast magnetic resonance imaging sequence and role of intravenous contrast administration in evaluation of perianal fistula with surgical correlation

Purpose To evaluate the best non-contrast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) sequence and role of intravenous contrast administration in preoperative characterization and classification of perianal fistulae, keeping surgery as gold standard. Methods This prospective study comprised of forty-five consecutive patients with actively draining external perianal opening. MRI was performed on a 1.5 T scanner using non-contrast and contrast enhanced sequences in multiple planes. St. James's University Hospital MRI based classification system was used to classify the fistulae into five grades. Taking surgery as gold standard, association between surgical and MRI findings was statistically analysed. Results Of the 45 patients recruited, forty were deemed eligible for inclusion. Mean age was 39.7 +/- 11.7 years with male preponderance (M: F = 8:1). Commonest type was Grade 1 (40%). The best sequences in terms of overall accuracy were axial & coronal planes of contrast enhanced fat suppressed (FS) T1W turbo spin echo (TSE) (95.7%) followed by FS T2W TSE (94.1%) while sagittal T2W TSE sequence with or without fat suppression had the lowest accuracy (90.13%). The difference in overall diagnostic accuracy of FS T2W TSE and contrast enhanced FS T1W TSE sequence for evaluating perianal fistula was not statistically significant (p = 0.52). However, contrast study had a better accuracy in detecting internal openings and secondary tract of recurrent/ post-operative cases. Conclusion Best non-contrast MRI sequence is FS T2W TSE (axial and coronal). Non-contrast MRI is equally efficient to contrast study while evaluating primary/previously unoperated cases thereby eliminating the role of contrast in such cases. However, intravenous contrast should be administered for evaluating post-operative cases with recurrence.