A new species of the eelpout genus Pachycara Zugmayer is described from the lower bathyal zone of central California, USA on the basis of three adult males. It is distinguished from its congeners mainly by its low vertebral counts, origin of the mediolateral branch of the lateral line system, lack of pelvic fins, presence of scales on the nape and cheeks and restricted gill slit. In addition, two species of the eelpout genus Lycenchelys Gill (L. micropora and L. monstrosa), taken in the same collection as the new Pachycara, are discussed, with the latter added to the California marine fish fauna.