Are thought experiments "disturbing"? The case of armchair physics

被引：4

作者：

Schindler, Samuel ^{[1
]}

Saint-Germier, Pierre ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] Aarhus Univ, Ny Munkegade 118, DK-8000 Aarhus, Denmark

来源：

PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES | 2020年 / 177卷 / 09期

关键词：

Method of cases; Disturbing characteristics; Machery; Armchair physics; Thought experiments; Experimental philosophy; EXPERTISE;

D O I：

10.1007/s11098-019-01333-w

中图分类号：

B [哲学、宗教];

学科分类号：

01 ; 0101 ;

摘要：

Proponents of the "negative program" in experimental philosophy have argued that judgements in philosophical cases, also known as case judgements, are unreliable and that the method of cases should be either strongly constrained or even abandoned. Here we put one of the main proponent's account of why philosophical cases may cause the unreliability of case judgements to the test. We conducted our test with thought experiments from physics, which exhibit the exact same supposedly "disturbing characteristics" of philosophical cases.

引用

页码：2671 / 2695

页数：25

共 50 条

[1] Are thought experiments “disturbing”? The case of armchair physics
Samuel Schindler
Pierre Saint-Germier
[J]. Philosophical Studies, 2020, 177 : 2671 - 2695
[2] PHILOSOPHICAL THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS: IN OR OUT OF THE ARMCHAIR?
Engel, Pascal
[J]. THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS IN METHODOLOGICAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXTS, 2011, 19 : 145 - 163
[3] Some Thought Experiments in Physics
Vishwamittar
[J]. Resonance, 2018, 23 (9) : 965 - 991
[4] On the Limitations of Thought Experiments in Physics and the Consequences for Physics Education
Miriam Reiner
Lior M. Burko
[J]. Science & Education, 2003, 12 (4) : 365 - 385
[5] The context of thought experiments in physics learning
Reiner M.
[J]. Interchange, 2006, 37 (1-2) : 97 - 113
[6] Thought experiments and collaborative learning in physics
Reiner, M
[J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENCE EDUCATION, 1998, 20 (09) : 1043 - 1058
[7] QUANTUM PHYSICS AND THEOLOGY: JOHN POLKINGHORNE ON THOUGHT EXPERIMENTS
Fehige, Yiftach J. H.
[J]. ZYGON, 2012, 47 (02): : 256 - 288
[8] Thought experiments in physics education: A simple and practical example
Lattery M.J.
[J]. Science & Education, 2001, 10 (5) : 485 - 492
[9] The Nature and Role of Thought Experiments in Solving Conceptual Physics Problems
Şule Dönertaş Kösem
Ömer Faruk Özdemir
[J]. Science & Education, 2014, 23 : 865 - 895
[10] The Nature and Role of Thought Experiments in Solving Conceptual Physics Problems
Kosem, Sule Donertas
Ozdemir, Omer Faruk
[J]. SCIENCE & EDUCATION, 2014, 23 (04) : 865 - 895

← 1 2 3 4 5 →