Participation and environmental policy in Canada and the United States: Trends over time

This article explores trends in participation and environmental policy in Canada and the United States over three time periods: from the early 1970s to the mid-1980s; from the mid-1980s to the early 1990s; and,finally, over the past few years. The article examines possible interactions among the two variables within each country over these periods and searches out overall tendencies toward convergence or divergence. The article argues that there was divergence between the two countries in the first period, with the U.S. providing more participatory opportunities earlier than Canada and establishing a more developed regulatory framework. An overview of progress over the second period, showing same convergence among the two countries, is then provided. Canada seemed to be catching up to its southern counterpart in terms of both participatory opportunities-although they took a distinctively Canadian form-and policy decisions. More recently, however, the trend has been toward divergence. The article explains that, over the past few years, participatory opportunities in Canada have been diminished and the environmental regulatory framework has been scaled back. Although there have been some changes in the U.S. case, the scale of these changes has not been as extensive. The final section of the article then attempts to relate these broader trends in participation and policy decisions to the political context in each country. it is argued that institutional frameworks in the two countries have played a key role in the identified trends. In particular, Canada's institutional structure-specifically the concentration of power in the executive and its federal structure-has hastened these recent developments, while the U.S. institutional framework-with its multiple power centers-has acted as a brake on those who advocate significant change to the existing environmental policy regime.