Objectives Understanding the disparity in clinical course because of differences in initial recurrence patterns could lead to a more accurate estimation of prognosis and optimal treatment. Methods Patients who underwent resection for pancreatic cancer between January 2003 and December 2016 were identified from a prospective database. We analyzed the association between clinicopathological information or survival outcomes and initial recurrence patterns. Results The most frequent recurrence pattern was locoregional recurrence (n = 84, 31.3%), followed by simultaneous multiple recurrences (n = 65, 24.2%), liver metastasis (n = 53, 19.8%), peritoneal dissemination (n = 41, 15.3%), and lung metastasis (n = 20, 7.5%). In addition, survival outcomes were significantly longer in the lung metastasis group than in the other recurrence pattern group (recurrence-free survival, 18.2 vs 8.2 months,P< 0.001; overall survival, 86.4 vs 21.0 months,P< 0.001; and survival after recurrence, 37.1 vs 9.3 months,P< 0.001). The lung metastasis group had a significantly higher proportion of pancreatic body and tail cancer (P< 0.002) and arterial invasion (P= 0.006) than the other recurrence pattern group. Conclusions Lung metastasis as an initial recurrence pattern frequently occurred in patients with body and tail cancer and patients with arterial invasion.