The effect of transversus abdominis plane block or local anaesthetic infiltration in inguinal hernia repair A randomised clinical trial

CONTEXTThe analgesic effect of transversus abdominis plane (TAP) block after inguinal hernia repair is unclear.OBJECTIVEThe aim of this randomised and double-blind study was to evaluate the analgesic effect of a TAP block in patients scheduled for primary inguinal hernia repair. The TAP block was evaluated versus placebo and versus an active comparator (ilioinguinal block and wound infiltration).DESIGNRandomised controlled trial.SETTINGSingle centre trial. Study period from June 2010 to November 2011.PATIENTSAdults (18 to 75 years) with American Society of Anesthesiologists' status 1-3 scheduled for primary inguinal hernia repair as day case surgery were included in the study.INTERVENTIONSNinety patients were allocated to one of three groups: group TAP, group infiltration (ilioinguinal nerve block and wound infiltration) and group placebo.MAIN OUTCOME MEASURESThe primary outcome measure was pain scores while coughing between group TAP and group placebo calculated as area under the curve for the first 24h (AUC(24h)). Secondary outcomes were pain scores while coughing and at rest, opioid consumption and side effects in groups TAP, infiltration and placebo.RESULTSVisual analogue pain scores while coughing and at rest demonstrated no difference between groups. Pain scores in groups infiltration, TAP and placebo were 19 versus 22 versus 15mm at rest (P=1.00) and 37 versus 41 versus 37mm while coughing (P=1.00). Pain scores at 6h (AUC(6h)) were significantly lower in group infiltration than in group TAP (10 versus 25mm at rest, P<0.001; 17 versus 40mm while coughing, P<0.001), and than in group placebo (10 versus 20mm at rest, P=0.003; 17 versus 38mm while coughing, P<0.001). Median morphine consumption was lower in group infiltration than in group placebo (0 versus 5mg, P<0.003). No differences among groups were demonstrated for ketobemidone consumption or side effects.CONCLUSIONUltrasound-guided TAP block did not reduce postoperative pain after inguinal hernia repair.