A Prospective, Randomized Trial Comparing the Short- and Long-term Results of Doppler-Guided Transanal Hemorrhoid Dearterialization With Mucopexy Versus Excision Hemorrhoidectomy for Grade III Hemorrhoids

被引:60
|
作者
De Nardi, Paola [1 ]
Capretti, Giovanni [1 ]
Corsaro, Antonino [2 ]
Staudacher, Carlo [1 ]
机构
[1] Ist Sci San Raffaele, Dept Surg, I-20132 Milan, Italy
[2] Univ Catania, Dept Surg, Catania, Italy
关键词
Hemorrhoids; Excision hemorrhoidectomy; Doppler-guided hemorrhoid dearterialization; Mucopexy; RECTO-ANAL-REPAIR; ARTERY LIGATION; RAR;
D O I
10.1097/DCR.0000000000000085
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
BACKGROUND: Few randomized trials have compared the results of Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoid dearterialization with mucopexy and excisional open hemorrhoidectomy. Few studies have reported long-term results. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to evaluate the results of Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoid dearterialization with mucopexy compared with excisional open hemorrhoidectomy in patients with grade III hemorrhoids. DESIGN: This is a prospective randomized study registered at clinicaltrials.gov (NCT01263431). A power analysis assessed the study's sample size. Patients were randomly assigned to undergo either hemorrhoidectomy or Doppler-guided hemorrhoid dearterialization plus mucopexy. The (2) test, Mann-Whitney U test, Student t test, and a regression model were used, as appropriate. SETTINGS: This study was conducted at the Department of Surgery, San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Milan, Italy. PATIENTS: Fifty consecutive patients were treated for grade III hemorrhoids from July to November 2010. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome was postoperative pain. The secondary outcomes included postoperative morbidity, the resumption of social and/or working activity, patient satisfaction, and the relapse of symptoms at 1 and 24 months. RESULTS: No major complications occurred in either group. The median visual analog scale scores for pain in the hemorrhoidectomy and Doppler-guided dearterialization plus mucopexy groups on days 1, 7, 14, and 30 were 7 vs 5.5, 3 vs 2.5, 1 vs 0, and 0 vs 0 (p> 0.05). The median work resumption day was the 22nd in the hemorrhoidectomy group and the 10th in the Doppler-guided dearterialization plus mucopexy group (p = 0.09). Patient satisfaction at 1 and 24 postoperative months, with the use of a 4-point scale, was 3 vs 4 and 4 vs 4 (p > 0.05). During the follow-up, 2 patients in the dearterialization group required ambulatory treatment, and 1 patient in each group required further surgery for symptom relapse. LIMITATIONS: Nonvalidated questionnaires were used in the follow-up. Cost analysis was not performed. CONCLUSION: Compared with hemorrhoidectomy, dearterialization with mucopexy resulted in similar postoperative pain and morbidity, and a similar long-term cure rate.
引用
收藏
页码:348 / 353
页数:6
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] PROSPECTIVE RANDOMIZED TRIAL COMPARING SHORT- AND LONG-TERM RESULTS OF DOPPLER-GUIDED TRANSANAL DEARTERIALIZATION AND HEMORRHOIDECTOMY FOR GRADE III HEMORRHOIDS.
    De Nardi, P.
    Capretti, G.
    Corsaro, A.
    Staudacher, C.
    [J]. DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2013, 56 (04) : E103 - E103
  • [2] Distal Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus conventional hemorrhoidectomy for grade III and IV hemorrhoids: postoperative morbidity and long-term outcomes
    L. Trenti
    S. Biondo
    A. Galvez
    A. Bravo
    J. Cabrera
    E. Kreisler
    [J]. Techniques in Coloproctology, 2017, 21 : 337 - 344
  • [3] Distal Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus conventional hemorrhoidectomy for grade III and IV hemorrhoids: postoperative morbidity and long-term outcomes
    Trenti, L.
    Biondo, S.
    Galvez, A.
    Bravo, A.
    Cabrera, J.
    Kreisler, E.
    [J]. TECHNIQUES IN COLOPROCTOLOGY, 2017, 21 (05) : 337 - 344
  • [4] PROSPECTIVE, RANDOMIZED TRIAL ON SURGICAL TREATMENT OF GRADE III HEMORRHOIDS: HEMORRHOIDECTOMY VERSUS DOPPLER-GUIDED TRANSANAL HEMORRHOIDAL DEARTERIALIZATION AND ANOPEXY.
    De Nardi, P.
    Capretti, G.
    Corsaro, A.
    Staudacher, C.
    [J]. DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2011, 54 (05) : E73 - E73
  • [5] Correction to: Distal Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus conventional hemorrhoidectomy for grade III and IV hemorrhoids: postoperative morbidity and long-term outcomes
    L. Trenti
    S. Biondo
    A. Galvez
    A. Bravo
    J. Cabrera
    E. Kreisler
    [J]. Techniques in Coloproctology, 2018, 22 : 479 - 479
  • [6] A prospective randomized trial of transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus ultrasonic scalpel hemorrhoidectomy for grade III hemorrhoids
    Tsunoda, A.
    Takahashi, T.
    Kusanagi, H.
    [J]. TECHNIQUES IN COLOPROCTOLOGY, 2017, 21 (08) : 657 - 665
  • [7] A prospective randomized trial of transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus ultrasonic scalpel hemorrhoidectomy for grade III hemorrhoids
    A. Tsunoda
    T. Takahashi
    H. Kusanagi
    [J]. Techniques in Coloproctology, 2017, 21 : 657 - 665
  • [8] Distal Doppler-guided transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization with mucopexy versus conventional hemorrhoidectomy for grade III and IV hemorrhoids: postoperative morbidity and long-term outcomes (vol 21, pg 337, 2017)
    Trenti, L.
    Biondo, S.
    Galvez, A.
    Bravo, A.
    Cabrera, J.
    Kreisler, E.
    [J]. TECHNIQUES IN COLOPROCTOLOGY, 2018, 22 (06) : 479 - 479
  • [9] PROSPECTIVE RANDOMIZED MULTICENTER STUDY COMPARING STAPLER HEMORRHOIDOPEXY (SH) WITH DOPPLER-GUIDED TRANSANAL HEMORRHOID DEARTERIALIZATION (THD) FOR III-DEGREE HEMORRHOIDS
    Altomare, D.
    Infantino, A.
    Bottini, C.
    Gentile, M.
    Buonanno, M.
    Hoch, J.
    Giamundo, P.
    Yalti, T.
    El Gaddal, A.
    Mancini, S.
    Pagano, C.
    [J]. DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2010, 53 (04) : 580 - 580
  • [10] Short-term Outcomes of Transanal Hemorrhoidal Dearterialization With Mucopexy Versus Vessel-Sealing Device Hemorrhoidectomy for Grade III to IV Hemorrhoids: A Prospective Randomized Multicenter Trial
    Trenti, Loris
    Biondo, Sebastiano
    Moreno, Esther Kreisler
    Sanchez-Garcia, Jose L.
    Espin-Basany, Eloy
    Landaluce-Olavarria, Aitor
    Bermejo-Marcos, Elena
    Garcia-Martinez, Maria T.
    Alias Jimenez, David
    Jimenez, Fernando
    Alonso, Adolfo
    Manso, Maria B.
    Frago, Ricardo
    Fraccalvieri, Domenico
    Golda, Thomas
    Galvez, Ana
    Sanzol, Maria R.
    Moreno, Ana
    Curell, Anna
    Tapiolas, Ingrid
    Garcia, Manuel
    Langara, Elena
    [J]. DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2019, 62 (08) : 988 - 996