Application of policy-led multi-criteria analysis to the project appraisal of the Northern Line Extension, London

被引:10
|
作者
Ward, E. John [1 ]
Dimitriou, Harry T. [1 ]
Wright, Phil [1 ]
Dean, Marco [1 ]
机构
[1] UCL, Bartlett Sch Planning, OMEGA Ctr, 14 Upper Woburn Pl, London WC1H 0NN, England
基金
英国工程与自然科学研究理事会;
关键词
Policy-led multi-criteria analysis; Megaprojects; Multi-stakeholders; Sustainable development; Distributional analysis;
D O I
10.1016/j.retrec.2016.08.004
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
This paper seeks to both illustrate and act as a proof of concept of how a policy-led multi-criteria analysis framework and its attendant process of the type introduced in the second paper, 'Theory and Background of Multi-Criteria Analysis: Toward a policy-led approach for mega transport project infrastructure appraisal', can be applied to the appraisal of a mega transport project in the form of the Northern Line Extension in London. It is offered with a view to help better identify the distribution of the projects costs and benefits and shed greater light on the possible 'winners' and 'losers' over space and time, and under given scenarios. Drawing from an extensive array of public domain literature the paper sets out both the policy and planning contexts for the project plus the business case that led to a decision by UK Treasury to guarantee a El billion loan to Transport for London for the construction of the Northern Line's extension. The paper looks at the scale and nature of the megaproject's features, particularly its line-haul and related real estate developments, especially those in the assigned development opportunity area. The text presents the policy, planning, legislative and regulative dimensions of the project likely to define its revenue generation prospects and environmental and social impacts, with special attention paid to those project outcomes affecting key stakeholders over time and space. The paper also seeks to explain the mechanics of how to employ a policy-led multi-criteria framework together with its associated processes within which stakeholder policies and agendas can be mapped and common/divergent interests identified. This is done with a view to ultimately facilitate stakeholder negotiation decision-making trade-offs in given scenarios under the policy guidance of the Greater London Authority with the support of the Treasury of the UK Government. (C) 2016 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
引用
收藏
页码:46 / 80
页数:35
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] The Application of Policy-Led Multi-Criteria Analysis to Transport Infrastructure Project Appraisal
    Dimitriou, Harry T.
    RESEARCH IN TRANSPORTATION ECONOMICS, 2016, 58 : 1 - 6
  • [2] Theory and background of multi-criteria analysis: Toward a policy-led approach to mega transport infrastructure project appraisal
    Ward, E. John
    Dimitriou, Harry T.
    Dean, Marco
    RESEARCH IN TRANSPORTATION ECONOMICS, 2016, 58 : 21 - 45
  • [3] The Planning and Appraisal of Mega Transport Infrastructure Projects Delivered by Public-Private Partnerships: The Case for the Use of Policy-Led Multi-Criteria Analysis
    Ward, John
    Dimitriou, Harry T.
    Field, Brian G.
    Dean, Marco
    ORGANIZATION TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION, 2019, 11 (01): : 1992 - 2008
  • [4] Presenting the case for the application of multi-criteria analysis to mega transport infrastructure project appraisal
    Dimitriou, Harry T.
    Ward, E. John
    Dean, Marco
    RESEARCH IN TRANSPORTATION ECONOMICS, 2016, 58 : 7 - 20
  • [5] Multi-Criteria Analysis for Policy Evaluation
    Drechsler, Martin
    EUROPEAN IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND THE ENVIRONMENT, 2010, : 119 - 129
  • [6] ANALYSIS OF A MULTI-CRITERIA PROJECT CRASHING MODEL
    MOORE, LJ
    TAYLOR, BW
    CLAYTON, ER
    LEE, SM
    AIIE TRANSACTIONS, 1978, 10 (02): : 163 - 169
  • [7] Multi-criteria Decision analysis for assessment and appraisal of Orphan Drugs
    Iskrov, Georgi
    Miteva-Katrandzhieva, Tsonka
    Stefanov, Rumen
    FRONTIERS IN PUBLIC HEALTH, 2016, 4
  • [8] Multi-criteria analysis of risks and phases in mining project
    Bogdanovic, Dejan
    Jovanovic, Ivan
    Stojanovic, Andelka
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 5TH IPMA SENET PROJECT MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (SENET 2019), 2019, 108 : 189 - 192
  • [9] The application of multi-criteria analysis to substation design
    Atanackovic, D
    McGillis, DT
    Galiana, FD
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, 1998, 13 (03) : 1172 - 1178
  • [10] APPLICATION OF NEW METHOD OF MULTI-CRITERIA ANALYSIS
    Jurica, L.
    Hradilek, Z.
    Dvorsky, J.
    Krejci, P.
    ADVANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC ENGINEERING, 2006, 5 (01) : 82 - 85