Management accountants' image, role and identity: employer branding and identity conflict

PurposeThis study aims to take a step toward integrating research regarding the image, role and identity of management accountants by understanding how employers' perceptions of the ideal management accountant image differ from operational managers' perceived role expectations, how management accountants perceive their identity and how those factors shape management accountants' understanding of who they are and want to be. Design/methodology/approachA qualitative design draws upon the case company's 100 job advertisements and 31 semi-structured interviews with management accountants and operational managers. Those data are entwined with role theory and its core concepts of expectations and identities and also early recruitment-related theoretical aspects such as image and employer branding. FindingsThe findings reveal how employers' perceptions of the ideal image and operational managers' role expectations shape and influence the identity of management accountants. However, management accountants distance themselves from a brand image and role expectations. They experience identity conflict between their current and desired identity, the perception of not being able to perform the currently desired role. Although this study presents some possible reasons and explanations, such as employer branding for the misalignment and discrepancy between perceptions of employer (image), expectations of operational managers (role) and management accountants' self-conception of the role (identity), this study argues that the identity of a management accountant results from organizational aspects of image and role and individual aspects of identity. Research limitations/implicationsImage and external role expectations can challenge identity construction and also serve as a source of conflict and frustration; thus, a more comprehensive approach to studying the identity of management accountants is necessary to understand what contributes to the fragility of their identity. Practical implicationsThe results provide an understanding of the dynamics of the image, role and identity to support management accountants and employers and to further address the suggested dissonance and ambiguities. Originality/valueThis study contributes by showing how the dynamics and connections between the image, role and identity influence the identity construction of management accountants. Moreover, this study shows how overpromising as a part of employer branding might not reflect the reality experienced by management accountants but may cause frustration and threaten the management accountants' identity.