Comments on "removal of methylene blue dye from aqueous solution using citric acid modified apricot stone"

被引：6

作者：

Bollinger, Jean-Claude ^{[1
]}

Hai Nguyen Tran ^{[2
,3
]}

Lima, Eder C. ^{[4
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Limoges, Fac Sci, Lab E2Lim, F-87060 Limoges, France

[2] Duy Tan Univ, Inst Fundamental & Appl Sci, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

[3] Duy Tan Univ, Fac Environm & Chem Engn, Da Nang, Vietnam

[4] Fed Univ Rio Grande do Sul UFRGS, Inst Chem, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil

来源：

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING COMMUNICATIONS | 2023年 / 210卷 / 09期

关键词：

Adsorption; comment; isotherm modeling; scientific mistake; thermodynamic parameter; THERMODYNAMIC PARAMETERS; ADSORPTION;

D O I：

10.1080/00986445.2022.2111556

中图分类号：

TQ [化学工业];

学科分类号：

0817 ;

摘要：

The work mentioned in the title of this comments-typed paper contains several calculations that disagree with some basic chemistry concepts. These misleading calculations mainly include (i) both kinetic and isotherm modeling through linear equations and (ii) calculating the thermodynamic parameters for the adsorption processes. Thus, we remind how to correct ways allowing to make these calculations. In our opinion, it is a source of confusion for the scientific community to continue using inappropriate methods as applied in the original paper.

引用

页码：1625 / 1630

页数：6

共 50 条

[1] Removal of methylene blue dye from aqueous solution using citric acid modified apricot stone
Kavci, Erbil
Erkmen, Julide
Bingol, M. Semih
[J]. CHEMICAL ENGINEERING COMMUNICATIONS, 2023, 210 (02) : 165 - 180
[2] Citric acid modified waste cigarette filters for adsorptive removal of methylene blue dye from aqueous solution
Tehrim, Aafia
Dai, Min
Wu, Xiange
Umair, Malik Muhammad
Ali, Imran
Amjed, Muhammad Ahsan
Rong, Rong
Javaid, Sheikh Fahad
Peng, Changsheng
[J]. JOURNAL OF APPLIED POLYMER SCIENCE, 2021, 138 (27)
[3] Citric acid modified kenaf core fibres for removal of methylene blue from aqueous solution
Sajab, Mohd Shaiful
Chia, Chin Hua
Zakaria, Sarani
Jani, Saad Mohd
Ayob, Mohd Khan
Chee, Kah Leong
Khiew, Poi Sim
Chiu, Wee Siong
[J]. BIORESOURCE TECHNOLOGY, 2011, 102 (15) : 7237 - 7243
[4] Adsorption of heavy metals and methylene blue from aqueous solution with citric acid modified peach stone
Yan, Junhua
Lan, Guihong
Qiu, Haiyan
Chen, Chao
Liu, Yongqiang
Du, Guoyong
Zhang, Jihong
[J]. SEPARATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, 2018, 53 (11) : 1678 - 1688
[5] REMOVAL OF METHYLENE BLUE DYE FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTION USING MODIFIED CELLULOSE HYDROGEL
Zhou Yiming
Fu Shiyu
Yang Shaoping
Li Xueyun
Zhan Huaiyu
[J]. RESEARCH PROGRESS IN PAPER INDUSTRY AND BIOREFINERY (4TH ISETPP), VOLS 1-3, 2010, : 1159 - 1162
[6] Biosorption of Methylene Blue from Aqueous Solution Using Lawny Grass Modified with Citric Acid
Chen, Lihua
Ramadan, Anas
Lue, Lili
Shao, Wenjing
Luo, Fang
Chen, Ji
[J]. JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL AND ENGINEERING DATA, 2011, 56 (08): : 3392 - 3399
[7] Removal of Methylene Blue in Aqueous Solution by Economic Adsorbent Derived from Apricot Stone Activated Carbon
Abbas, Moussa
Trari, Mohamed
[J]. FIBERS AND POLYMERS, 2020, 21 (04) : 810 - 820
[8] Removal of Methylene Blue in Aqueous Solution by Economic Adsorbent Derived from Apricot Stone Activated Carbon
Moussa Abbas
Mohamed Trari
[J]. Fibers and Polymers, 2020, 21 : 810 - 820
[9] Removal of methylene blue dye aqueous solution using photocatalysis
Joshi, K. M.
Shrivastava, V. S.
[J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NANO DIMENSION, 2012, 2 (04) : 241 - 252
[10] Removal of methylene blue dye from aqueous solution by using orange peel treated with acid as an adsorbent
Zainol, Noor Ainee
Baharuddin, Asma
Yusoff, Nor Aida
Sohaimi, Khairunissa Syairah Ahmad
Rohaizad, Nor Munirah
Ghani, Azlinda Abdul
Wikurendra, Edza Aria
Andini, Ary
Syafiuddin, Achmad
[J]. DESALINATION AND WATER TREATMENT, 2022, 260 : 161 - 168

← 1 2 3 4 5 →