Restitution versus repatriation: Terminology and concepts matter

被引:1
|
作者
Rassool, Ciraj [1 ,3 ]
Gibbon, Victoria E. [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Western Cape, Dept Hist Studies, Cape Town, South Africa
[2] Univ Cape Town, Dept Human Biol, Div Clin Anat & Biol Anthropol, Cape Town, South Africa
[3] Univ Western Cape, Dept Hist Studies, Ciraj Rassool, Cape Town, South Africa
来源
基金
新加坡国家研究基金会;
关键词
human remains; museum; reconciliation; repair; restitution; restitutionary work; restoration;
D O I
10.1002/ajpa.24889
中图分类号
Q98 [人类学];
学科分类号
030303 ;
摘要
IntroductionThrough museum collecting practice, the deceased, possessions, plants and animals were turned into objects, removed from their communities and places of origin, and were segregated and divided into museum classificatory systems. In the decolonial work of embarking upon purposeful and proactive acts of return, the terms "repatriation" and "restitution" have often been used interchangeably.ObjectiveTo assess the terminological differences between repatriation and restitution.MethodsHere, we critically discuss the politics of these terms and present an argument for restitution as restitutionary work.ResultsRepatriation refers to the legal, administrative and logistical matters of returning across national borders. However, restitution is a preferred concept highlighting deeper meanings of return to the proper owner, with restitutionary work being time-consuming, emotional, often painful, enriching acts of restoration, and transitional justice. Restitution is about the embodiment and empowerment of choice over all aspects of the return.ConclusionHere, we argue that terminology matters. While restitution may involve repatriation, repatriation is not a substitute for acts of restoration embodied in restitutionary work. Restitution word cloud.image
引用
收藏
页数:4
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Restitution unraveled Reflections on museum objects in times of repatriation and restitution
    Van Beurden, Jos
    Adams, Kathleen M.
    Catteeuw, Paul
    [J]. VOLKSKUNDE, 2019, 120 (03): : 305 - 323
  • [2] BEYOND REPATRIATION - A PROPOSAL FOR THE EQUITABLE RESTITUTION OF CULTURAL PROPERTY
    DAVIS, AJ
    [J]. UCLA LAW REVIEW, 1985, 33 (02) : 642 - 663
  • [3] Repatriation and restitution of Holocaust victims in post-war Denmark
    Bak, Sofie Lene
    [J]. JEWISH STUDIES IN THE NORDIC COUNTRIES TODAY, 2016, 27 : 134 - 152
  • [4] Returns Unraveled Reflections on Museum Objects in an Age of Repatriation and Restitution
    Van Beurden, Jos
    Adams, Kathleen M.
    Catteeuw, Paul
    [J]. VOLKSKUNDE, 2019, 120 (03): : 325 - 339
  • [5] Why Does Repatriation Matter?
    Colwell, Chip
    [J]. ENGAGED ARCHAEOLOGY IN THE SOUTHWESTERN UNITED STATES AND NORTHWESTERN MEXICO, 2021, : 133 - 138
  • [6] PACEMAKER CONCEPTS AND TERMINOLOGY
    BERKOVITS, BV
    [J]. MEDICAL COLLEGE OF VIRGINIA QUARTERLY, 1971, 7 (04): : 131 - +
  • [7] STRATIGRAPHIC CONCEPTS AND TERMINOLOGY
    CALVERT, WL
    [J]. AAPG BULLETIN-AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF PETROLEUM GEOLOGISTS, 1978, 62 (03): : 502 - 502
  • [8] A MATTER OF TERMINOLOGY
    DEALMEIDA, JMR
    [J]. PEDIATRICS, 1991, 88 (01) : 180 - 180
  • [9] Thinking about cultural heritage through the repatriation and restitution of cultural objects
    da Costa, Karine Lima
    [J]. PATRIMONIO E MEMORIA, 2018, 14 (02): : 256 - 271
  • [10] Two concepts of injustice in restitution for slavery
    Sebok, AJ
    [J]. BOSTON UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW, 2004, 84 (05) : 1405 - 1442