Wave turbulence in geophysical flows

Despite elegant theoretical descriptions and numerous potential applications in nature, the various features of wave turbulence and its associated transfers across scales are still debated. One reason is the difficulty, both experimentally and numerically, of studying a chaotic nonlinear wavy system with sufficient precision, over a sufficient duration, and with sufficient separation between the injection scale, the system scale and the dissipation scale, to dwell in detail on the description of a statistically converged state. The numerical study of Thomas & Ding (J. Fluid Mech., 2023, this issue) sheds new light on one key aspect of this global problem: the upscale transfer of waves in rotating shallow water equations, which is of relevance to atmosphere and ocean dynamics. Their results first confirm the theoretical predictions, with a robust inverse wave cascade, a predominant role of quartic resonances and a slope value of the wave spectrum in agreement with the expected range. But their deeper analysis of the results also highlights some weakness in the theoretical foundations, exhibiting strong intermittency and departure from ideal Gaussian statistics. This work thus calls for improved modelling, acknowledging that important large-scale climatic features could actually result from the piling up of small-scale waves, unresolved by typical Earth system models. Beyond rotating shallow water systems, this study more generically resonates with open questions in the field of wave turbulence and its geophysical applications, including recent research in deep rotating and stably stratified systems.