Comparison of machine learning approaches for the classification of elution profiles

Hyphenated chromatography is among the most popular analytical techniques in omics related research. While great advancements have been achieved on the experimental side, the same is not true for the extraction of the relevant information from chromatographic data. Extensive signal preprocessing is required to remove the signal of the baseline, resolve the time shifts of peaks from sample to sample and to properly estimate the spectra and concentrations of co-eluting compounds. Among several available strategies, curve resolution approaches, such as PARAFAC2, ease the deconvolution and the quantification of chemicals. However, not all resolved profiles are relevant. For example, some take into account the baseline, others the chemical compounds. Thus, it is necessary to distinguish the profiles describing relevant chemistry. With the aim to assist researchers in this selection phase, we have tried three different classification algorithms (convolutional and recurrent neural networks, k-nearest neighbours) for the automatic identification of GC-MS elution profiles resolved by PARAFAC2. To this end, we have manually labelled more than 170,000 elution profiles in the following four classes: 'Peak', 'Cutoff peak',' Baseline' and 'Others' in order to train, validate and test the classification models. The results highlight two main points: i) neural networks seem to be the best solution for this specific classification task confirmed by the overall quality of the classification, ii) the quality of the input data is crucial to maximize the modelling performances.