The US Supreme Court and Affirmative Action: The Negative Impact on the Physician Workforce

Purpose: Maintaining admissions of underrepresented students to medical schools is essential to securing a diverse health care workforce. Empirical evidence indicates that minority patients may prefer practitioners of their own race. The recent US Supreme Court decision concerning affirmative action makes this goal more difficult, but medical schools can still work within the language of the law to redouble their efforts to seat a diverse class of medical students. Methods: We examined the literature correlating the availability of minority physicians and the health outcomes of the patients they serve. We also examined the literature on race-conscious policies of medical schools intended to address the shortage of minority physicians considering the benefits achieved through a diverse field of health care workers. We also examined the law and the recent US Supreme Court opinion, including the application of equal protection principles, to suggest strategies to seat a diverse class of students within the scope of the law. Findings: Institutions have maintained the status quo of disparate distributions of professions by race through structural biases that also limit access to medical schools. The new US Supreme Court decision is expected to exacerbate this disparity unless medical schools engage in admissions protocols that actively solicit the character and unique abilities that each of the applicants can offer to contribute to the medical school and the health care profession. Implications: The new US Supreme Court mandate is likely to create challenges for medical schools in their efforts to recruit and seat minority applicants. The mandate provides little discussion, suggesting a lack of understanding of the downstream public health consequences to patients if medical school applicants are denied the benefits of race-conscious admissions policies. Nevertheless, the language of the US Supreme Court's opinion may provide a viable path forward, at least with respect to medical schools where the need for a diverse pool of health care practitioners is particularly compelling.