Retrieval accuracy and stability of two operational aerosol retrieval algorithms, Deep Blue (DB) and Dark Target (DT), applied on Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite (VIIRS) on-board Suomi National Polar-orbiting Partnership (S-NPP) satellite were evaluated over South Asia. The region is reported to be highly challenging to accurate estimation of satellite-based aerosol optical properties due to variations in surface reflectance, complex aerosol system and regional meteorology. Performance of both algorithms were initially evaluated by comparing their ability to retrieve aerosol signal over the complex geographical region under specific air pollution emission scenario. Thereafter, retrieval accuracy was investigated against 10 AERONET sites across South Asia, selected based on their geography and predominance aerosol types, from year 2012-2021. Geospatial analysis indicates DB to efficiently retrieve fine aerosol features over bright arid surfaces, and for smoke/dust dominating events whereas DT was better to identify small fire events under dark vegetated surface. Both algorithms however, indicate unsatisfactory retrieval accuracy against AERONET having 56-59% of valid retrievals with high RMSE (0.30-0.33) and bias. Overall, DB slightly underpredicted AOD with -0.02 mean bias (MB) whereas DT overpredicted AOD (MB: 0.13), with seasonality in their retrieval efficiency against AERONET. Time-series analysis indicates stability in retrieving AOD and match-up number for both algorithms. Retrieval bias of DB and DT AOD against AERONET AOD under diverse aerosol loading, aerosol size, scattering/absorbing aerosol, and surface vegetation coverage scenarios revealed DT to be more influenced by these conditions. Error analysis indicates at low AOD (& LE;0.2), accuracy of both DB and DT were subject to underlying vegetation coverage. At AOD>0.2, DB performed well in retrieving coarse aerosols whereas DT was superior when fine aerosols dominated. Overall, accuracy of both VIIRS algorithms require further refinement to continue MODIS AOD legacy over South Asia.
