Deductive system;
Boole's logic;
Aristotles' deductions;
syllogism;
algebra of logic;
D O I:
10.1080/01445340.2023.2271540
中图分类号:
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号:
摘要:
George Boole published the pamphlet The Mathematical Analysis of Logic in 1847. He believed that logic should belong to a universal mathematics that would cover both quantitative and nonquantitative research. With his pamphlet, Boole signalled an important change in symbolic logic: in contrast with his predecessors, his thinking was exclusively extensional. Notwithstanding the innovations introduced he accepted all traditional Aristotelean syllogisms. Nevertheless, some criticisms have been raised concerning Boole's view of Aristotelean logic as the solution of algebraic equations. In order to circumvent such criticisms, we show here how Boole's conclusions may be deduced from the axioms and inference rules proposed in his pamphlet, from which Aristotle's deductions in Prior Analytics (including those that are completed through an impossibility) can be stated as theorems. We clarify his method for dealing with both universal and particular premises by means of his symbol v and demystify some criticisms concerning the way he expressed particular premises. Boole's conclusions for some of those premises for which according to Aristotle there is no deduction are also discussed. The deductive system presented here has the potential to provide a new perspective on Boole's approach to logic in The Mathematical Analysis of Logic.
机构:
John Paul II Catholic Univ Lublin, Inst Philosophy, PL-20950 Lublin, PolandJohn Paul II Catholic Univ Lublin, Inst Philosophy, PL-20950 Lublin, Poland