Assessing Clinical Acumen in Predicting Acute Appendicitis in Emergency Surgery: A Prospective Study

Background Clinical acumen and experience are critical in the diagnosis of the commonest surgical emergency, acute appendicitis. However, there is an increasing focus on haematological and radiological parameters in reaching the diagnosis of appendicitis, which can negate the importance of clinical findings. The aim was to assess the accuracy of each grade of the surgical team in diagnosing acute appendicitis using clinical acuity alone and compare them to each other as well as validated predictive scores. Methods A prospective single-centre study was performed over a six-month period (Dec 2020-May 2021). All patients presenting to the emergency department with right iliac fossa pain were included. Results A total of 180 patients were included of whom 35% were male. Mean age was 36.2 years (range 16 & mdash;91). 51.1% had a final diagnosis of appendicitis, of which 91.3% were managed surgically and 8.7% were treated conservatively with antibiotics. Consultants were correct in their prediction of appendicitis in 84.6% of cases (females & mdash;83.4%, males & mdash;86.6%). Registrars accurately predicted appendicitis in 82.2% of patients (females & mdash;80.3%, males & mdash;85.7%), whilst house officers (SHOs) and interns were right in 73.8% (females & mdash;69.2%, males & mdash;82.5%) and 72.7% (females & mdash;66.6%, males & mdash;83.9%) of cases, respectively. In patients with a histological or radiological diagnosis of appendicitis, the mean Acute Inflammatory Response Score and Acute Appendicitis Score were 7.0 (high risk >= 9) and 12.5 (high risk >= 16), respectively. Clinicians had superior diagnostic accuracy when compared with both the clinical scores used. Conclusion Seniority was associated with improved diagnostic accuracy in clinically predicting acute appendicitis. This study showed that the clinical judgement of experienced surgeons is more reliable than clinical scores in the diagnosis of appendicitis.