Evaluating the accuracy of liquid permeability measurements in shale and tight rocks using transient flow method and comparison with gas permeability

The transient flow method for measuring permeability to liquid is a useful technique for shale and tight rocks; however, it is not as popular as the steady-state method in these rocks. One of the issues is the lack of clarity on a key term of compressibility of the fluid and rock system. Various forms of compressibility have been used in literature, which can lead to inconsistent results of liquid permeability. Using gas for the permeability measurement is more common in shale, and the Klinkenberg corrected permeability is often used to represent liquid permeability; however, how the Klinkenberg permeability is compared to liquid permeability in shale or tight rocks is not adequately addressed. This paper presents a study using the transient flow method for water and oil permeability measurement in three Eagle Ford Shale samples. Gas permeability was also measured for these samples. Different forms of the total compressibility of the fluid-rock system (C-t) are summarized from literature, and a new form of C-t is proposed. The accuracy of the calculations based on different forms of C-t is evaluated through the comparison between water and oil permeabilities and the comparison with gas permeability. The results are also compared with oil permeability obtained from the steady-state method. The new form of C-t provided the most accurate results, whereas the other forms of C-t led to errors. However, for samples with bulk compressibility of less than 1 x 10(-7) psi(-1), the error using those forms of C-t was negligible. The study also found that the Klinkenberg permeability obtained from the linear extrapolation is larger than the oil permeability for two samples by 12% and 37%, respectively, whereas it is smaller than the oil permeability for the other sample. This comparison suggests that a nonlinear gas slippage effect may exist in the high pressure range (>2000 psi) for shale or tight rock samples.