Competing chiral d-wave superconductivity and magnetic phases in the strong-coupling Hubbard model on the honeycomb lattice

We address the competing superconducting and magnetic phases on the honeycomb lattice, in a field-theoretic approach suitable to yield a low-energy perturbative theory for the strong-coupling limit of the Hubbard model, both at half filling and in the low and high hole-doped regimes. The effective low-lying Hamiltonian is presented in terms of charge (Grassmann fields) and spin [SU(2) gauge fields] degrees of freedom. We analyze the competing phases by calculating the ground-state energy, electronic spectrum, and other observables associated with the s- and dx2-y2 + idxy-wave superconducting phases, doped antiferromagnetic, and doped ferromagnetic states. We find that, while the antiferromagnetic order has the lowest ground-state energy for low hole doping near half filling, a dominant superconducting state with chiral dx2-y2 + idxy-wave symmetry emerges in the vicinity of the Van Hove singularity in the high hole-doped regime, with the presence of a quantum first-order transition accompanied by spatial phase separation. We highlight that advances in the understanding of chiral superconducting states on the honeycomb lattice are relevant to a number of doped compounds including the graphene monolayer system.