Quantifying the global 'CMB tension' between the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the Planck satellite in extended models of cosmology

被引:22
|
作者
Di Valentino, Eleonora [1 ]
Giare, William [2 ,3 ]
Melchiorri, Alessandro [4 ,5 ]
Silk, Joseph [6 ,7 ,8 ,9 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sheffield, Sch Math & Stat, Hounsfield Rd, Sheffield S3 7RH, England
[2] Ctr Nazl INFN Avanzati, Galileo Galileo Inst Theoret Phys, Largo Enrico Fermi 2, I-50125 Florence, Italy
[3] INFN, Sez Roma, Ple A Moro 2, I-00185 Rome, Italy
[4] Univ Roma La Sapienza, Phys Dept, Ple Aldo Moro 2, I-00185 Rome, Italy
[5] Univ Roma La Sapienza, INFN, Ple Aldo Moro 2, I-00185 Rome, Italy
[6] CNRS, Inst Astrophys Paris, UMR7095, F-75014 Paris, France
[7] Sorbonne Univ, UPMC, F-75014 Paris, France
[8] Johns Hopkins Univ, Dept Phys & Astron, Homewood Campus, Baltimore, MD 21218 USA
[9] Univ Oxford, Dept Phys, BIPAC, Keble Rd, Oxford OX1 3RH, England
关键词
cosmic background radiation; cosmological parameters; cosmology: observations; HUBBLE-SPACE-TELESCOPE; CONSTRAINTS; UNIVERSE; TEMPERATURE; MAPS;
D O I
10.1093/mnras/stad152
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
We study the global agreement between the most recent observations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature and polarization anisotropies angular power spectra released by the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the Planck satellite in various cosmological models that differ by the inclusion of different combinations of additional parameters. By using the Suspiciousness statistic, we show that the global "CMB tension' between the two experiments, quantified at the Gaussian equivalent le vel of similar to 2 . 5 sigma within the baseline Lambda cold dark matter, is reduced at the level of 1.8 sigma when the ef fecti ve number of relativistic particles (N-eff) is significantly less than the standard value, while it ranges between 2 . 3 sigma and 3 . 5 sigma in all the other extended models.
引用
收藏
页码:210 / 215
页数:6
相关论文
共 15 条
  • [1] Tickling the CMB damping tail: Scrutinizing the tension between the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and South Pole Telescope experiments
    Di Valentino, Eleonora
    Galli, Silvia
    Lattanzi, Massimiliano
    Melchiorri, Alessandro
    Natoli, Paolo
    Pagano, Luca
    Said, Najla
    PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 2013, 88 (02)
  • [2] The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: cross correlation with Planck maps
    Louis, Thibaut
    Addison, Graeme E.
    Hasselfield, Matthew
    Bond, J. Richard
    Calabrese, Erminia
    Das, Sudeep
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Dunkley, Joanna
    Duenner, Rolando
    Gralla, Megan
    Hajian, Amir
    Hincks, Adam D.
    Hlozek, Renee
    Huffenberger, Kevin
    Infante, Leopoldo
    Kosowsky, Arthur
    Marriage, Tobias A.
    Moodley, Kavilan
    Naess, Sigurd
    Niemack, Michael D.
    Nolta, Michael R.
    Page, Lyman A.
    Partridge, Bruce
    Sehgal, Neelima
    Sievers, Jonathan L.
    Spergel, David N.
    Staggs, Suzanne T.
    Walter, Benjamin Z.
    Wollack, Edward J.
    JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2014, (07):
  • [3] The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: likelihood for small-scale CMB data
    Dunkley, J.
    Calabrese, E.
    Sievers, J.
    Addison, G. E.
    Battaglia, N.
    Battistelli, E. S.
    Bond, J. R.
    Das, S.
    Devlin, M. J.
    Duenner, R.
    Fowler, J. W.
    Gralla, M.
    Hajian, A.
    Halpern, M.
    Hasselfield, M.
    Hincks, A. D.
    Hlozek, R.
    Hughes, J. P.
    Irwin, K. D.
    Kosowsky, A.
    Louis, T.
    Marriage, T. A.
    Marsden, D.
    Menanteau, F.
    Moodley, K.
    Niemack, M.
    Nolta, M. R.
    Page, L. A.
    Partridge, B.
    Sehgal, N.
    Spergel, D. N.
    Staggs, S. T.
    Switzer, E. R.
    Trac, H.
    Wollack, E.
    JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2013, (07):
  • [4] The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: CMB polarization at 200 < l < 9000
    Naess, Sigurd
    Hasselfield, Matthew
    McMahon, Jeff
    Niemack, Michael D.
    Addison, Graeme E.
    Ade, Peter A. R.
    Allison, Rupert
    Amiri, Mandana
    Battaglia, Nick
    Beall, James A.
    de Bernardis, Francesco
    Bond, J. Richard
    Britton, Joe
    Calabrese, Erminia
    Cho, Hsiao-mei
    Coughlin, Kevin
    Crichton, Devin
    Das, Sudeep
    Datta, Rahul
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Dicker, Simon R.
    Dunkley, Joanna
    Duenner, Rolando
    Fowler, Joseph W.
    Fox, Anna E.
    Gallardo, Patricio
    Grace, Emily
    Gralla, Megan
    Hajian, Amir
    Halpern, Mark
    Henderson, Shawn
    Hill, J. Colin
    Hilton, Gene C.
    Hilton, Matt
    Hincks, Adam D.
    Hlozek, Renee
    Ho, Patty
    Hubmayr, Johannes
    Huffenberger, Kevin M.
    Hughes, John P.
    Infante, Leopoldo
    Irwin, Kent
    Jackson, Rebecca
    Kasanda, Simon Muya
    Klein, Jeff
    Koopman, Brian
    Kosowsky, Arthur
    Li, Dale
    Louis, Thibaut
    Lungu, Marius
    JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2014, (10):
  • [5] ComPACT: combined Atacama Cosmology Telescope plus Planck galaxy cluster catalogue
    Voskresenskaia, S.
    Meshcheryakov, A.
    Lyskova, N.
    MONTHLY NOTICES OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY, 2024, 531 (01) : 1998 - 2010
  • [6] The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Cosmology from Cross-correlations of unWISE Galaxies and ACT DR6 CMB Lensing
    Farren, Gerrit S.
    Krolewski, Alex
    MacCrann, Niall
    Ferraro, Simone
    Abril-Cabezas, Irene
    An, Rui
    Atkins, Zachary
    Battaglia, Nicholas
    Bond, J. Richard
    Calabrese, Erminia
    Choi, Steve K.
    Darwish, Omar
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Duivenvoorden, Adriaan J.
    Dunkley, Jo
    Hill, J. Colin
    Hilton, Matt
    Huffenberger, Kevin M.
    Kim, Joshua
    Louis, Thibaut
    Madhavacheril, Mathew S.
    Marques, Gabriela A.
    McMahon, Jeff
    Moodley, Kavilan
    Page, Lyman A.
    Partridge, Bruce
    Qu, Frank J.
    Schaan, Emmanuel
    Sehgal, Neelima
    Sherwin, Blake D.
    Sifon, Cristobal
    Staggs, Suzanne T.
    Van Engelen, Alexander
    Vargas, Cristian
    Wenzl, Lukas
    White, Martin
    Wollack, Edward J.
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 2024, 966 (02):
  • [7] THE ATACAMA COSMOLOGY TELESCOPE: LENSING OF CMB TEMPERATURE AND POLARIZATION DERIVED FROM COSMIC INFRARED BACKGROUND CROSS-CORRELATION
    van Engelen, Alexander
    Sherwin, Blake D.
    Sehgal, Neelima
    Addison, Graeme E.
    Allison, Rupert
    Battaglia, Nick
    de Bernardis, Francesco
    Bond, J. Richard
    Calabrese, Erminia
    Coughlin, Kevin
    Crichton, Devin
    Datta, Rahul
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Dunkley, Joanna
    Duenner, Rolando
    Gallardo, Patricio
    Grace, Emily
    Gralla, Megan
    Hajian, Amir
    Hasselfield, Matthew
    Henderson, Shawn
    Hill, J. Colin
    Hilton, Matt
    Hincks, Adam D.
    Hlozek, Renee
    Huffenberger, Kevin M.
    Hughes, John P.
    Koopman, Brian
    Kosowsky, Arthur
    Louis, Thibaut
    Lungu, Marius
    Madhavacheril, Mathew
    Maurin, Loic
    McMahon, Jeff
    Moodley, Kavilan
    Munson, Charles
    Naess, Sigurd
    Nati, Federico
    Newburgh, Laura
    Niemack, Michael D.
    Nolta, Michael R.
    Page, Lyman A.
    Pappas, Christine
    Partridge, Bruce
    Schmitt, Benjamin L.
    Sievers, Jonathan L.
    Simon, Sara
    Spergel, David N.
    Staggs, Suzanne T.
    Switzer, Eric R.
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 2015, 808 (01):
  • [8] Atacama Cosmology Telescope: A measurement of the thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect using the skewness of the CMB temperature distribution
    Wilson, Michael J.
    Sherwin, Blake D.
    Hill, J. Colin
    Addison, Graeme
    Battaglia, Nick
    Bond, J. Richard
    Das, Sudeep
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Dunkley, Joanna
    Duenner, Rolando
    Fowler, Joseph W.
    Gralla, Megan B.
    Hajian, Amir
    Halpern, Mark
    Hilton, Matt
    Hincks, Adam D.
    Hlozek, Renee
    Huffenberger, Kevin
    Hughes, John P.
    Kosowsky, Arthur
    Louis, Thibaut
    Marriage, Tobias A.
    Marsden, Danica
    Menanteau, Felipe
    Moodley, Kavilan
    Niemack, Michael D.
    Nolta, Michael R.
    Page, Lyman A.
    Partridge, Bruce
    Reese, Erik D.
    Sehgal, Neelima
    Sievers, Jon
    Spergel, David N.
    Staggs, Suzanne T.
    Swetz, Daniel S.
    Switzer, Eric R.
    Trac, Hy
    Wollack, Ed
    PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 2012, 86 (12):
  • [9] Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Component-separated maps of CMB temperature and the thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect
    Madhavacheril, Mathew S.
    Hill, J. Colin
    Naess, Sigurd
    Addison, Graeme E.
    Aiola, Simone
    Baildon, Taylor
    Battaglia, Nicholas
    Bean, Rachel
    Bond, J. Richard
    Calabrese, Erminia
    Calafut, Victoria
    Choi, Steve K.
    Darwish, Omar
    Datta, Rahul
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Dunkley, Joanna
    Dunner, Rolando
    Ferraro, Simone
    Gallardo, Patricio A.
    Gluscevic, Vera
    Halpern, Mark
    Han, Dongwon
    Hasselfield, Matthew
    Hilton, Matt
    Hincks, Adam D.
    Hlozek, Renee
    Ho, Shuay-Pwu Patty
    Huffenberger, Kevin M.
    Hughes, John P.
    Koopman, Brian J.
    Kosowsky, Arthur
    Lokken, Martine
    Louis, Thibaut
    Lungu, Marius
    MacInnis, Amanda
    Maurin, Loic
    McMahon, Jeffrey J.
    Moodley, Kavilan
    Nati, Federico
    Niemack, Michael D.
    Page, Lyman A.
    Partridge, Bruce
    Robertson, Naomi
    Sehgal, Neelima
    Schaan, Emmanuel
    Schillaci, Alessandro
    Sherwin, Blake D.
    Sifon, Cristobal
    Simon, Sara M.
    Spergel, David N.
    PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 2020, 102 (02)
  • [10] The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: A Measurement of the DR6 CMB Lensing Power Spectrum and Its Implications for Structure Growth
    Qu, Frank
    Sherwin, Blake D.
    Madhavacheril, Mathew S.
    Han, Dongwon
    Crowley, Kevin T.
    Abril-Cabezas, Irene
    Ade, Peter A. R.
    Aiola, Simone
    Alford, Tommy
    Amiri, Mandana
    Amodeo, Stefania
    An, Rui
    Atkins, Zachary
    Austermann, Jason E.
    Battaglia, Nicholas
    Battistelli, Elia Stefano
    Beall, James A.
    Bean, Rachel
    Beringue, Benjamin
    Bhandarkar, Tanay
    Biermann, Emily
    Bolliet, Boris
    Bond, J. Richard
    Cai, Hongbo
    Calabrese, Erminia
    Calafut, Victoria
    Capalbo, Valentina
    Carrero, Felipe
    Carron, Julien
    Challinor, Anthony
    Chesmore, Grace E.
    Cho, Hsiao-Mei
    Choi, Steve K.
    Clark, Susan E.
    Rosado, Rodrigo Cordova
    Cothard, Nicholas F.
    Coughlin, Kevin
    Coulton, William
    Dalal, Roohi
    Darwish, Omar
    Devlin, Mark J.
    Dicker, Simon
    Doze, Peter
    Duell, Cody J.
    Duff, Shannon M.
    Duivenvoorden, Adriaan J.
    Dunkley, Jo
    Dunner, Rolando
    Fanfani, Valentina
    Fankhanel, Max
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 2024, 962 (02):