A mixed method study of DevOps challenges

Context: DevOps practices combine software development and IT (Information Technology) operations. The continuous needs for rapid but quality software development requires the adoption of high-quality DevOps tools. There is a growing number of DevOps related posts in popular online developer forum Stack Overflow (SO). While previous research analyzed SO posts related to build/release engineering, we are aware of no research that specifically focused on DevOps related discussions.Objective: This paper aims to learn the challenges developers face while using the currently available DevOps tools and techniques along with the organizational challenges in DevOps practices. Method: We conduct an empirical study by applying topic modeling on 174K SO posts that contain DevOps discussions. We then validate and extend the empirical study findings with a survey of 21 professional DevOps practitioners.Results: We find that: (1) There are 23 DevOps topics grouped into four categories: Cloud & CI/CD Tools, Infrastructure as Code, Container & Orchestration, and Quality Assurance. (2) The topic category 'Cloud & CI/CD Tools' contains the highest number of topics (10) which cover 48.6% of all questions in our dataset, followed by the category Infrastructure as Code (28.9%). (3) The file management is the most popular topic followed by Jenkins Pipeline, while infrastructural Exception Handling and Jenkins Distributed Architecture are the most difficult topics (with least accepted answers). (4) In the survey, developers mention that it requires hands-on experience before current DevOps tools can be considered easy. They raised the needs for better documentation and learning resources to learn the rapidly changing DevOps tools and techniques. Practitioners also emphasized on the formal training approach by the organizations for DevOps skill development.Conclusion: Architects and managers can use the findings of this research to adopt appropriate DevOps technologies, and organizations can design tool or process specific DevOps training programs.