Evaluation of Sub-Antarctic and Antarctic sea urchins' thermal reaction norm through righting behavior and comparison with in situ measurements

Sea urchin's survival may depend on their capacity to recover proper orientation rapidly and effectively after inversion, enabling escape from predator and preventing desiccation. This righting behavior has been used as a repeatable and reliable indicator to assess echinoderms performance across environmental conditions, including thermal sensitivity and thermal stress. The current study aims at evaluating and comparing the thermal reaction norm for righting behavior (time for righting (TFR) and capacity to self-right) of three common sea urchins from high latitude, the Patagonian sea urchins Loxechinus albus and Pseudechinus magellanicus, and the Antarctic sea urchin Sterechinus neumayeri. In addition, to infer the ecological implications of our experiments, we compared laboratory-based and in situ TFR of these three species. We observed that populations of the Patagonian sea urchins L. albus and P. magellanicus presented similar trend of righting behavior, overly accelerating with increasing temperature (from 0 to 22 degrees C). Little variations and high inter-individual variability were observed below 6 degrees C in the Antarctic sea urchin TFR, and righting success strongly decreased between 7 and 11 degrees C. For the three species, TFR was lower in in situ experiments compared to the laboratory. Overall, our results suggest that the populations of Patagonian sea urchin exhibit a wide thermal tolerance and, based on S. neumayeri's TFR, aligning with the narrow thermal tolerance of Antarctic benthos. Finally, the differences between laboratory and in situ experiments highlights the importance of considering the complexity of marine environments for future predictions.