Experimental assessment of the yield gap associated with maize production in the North China Plain

In order to improve the grain yield of food crops, which is necessary to ensure food security, it is crucial to narrow existing yield gaps. Quantitative analyses of crop yield gaps can provide theoretical support for ascer-taining the primary cause of these yield gaps, and then it can be used to increase the grain yield. We evaluated the size and characteristics of the summer maize yield gap in the North China Plain by combining crop models, farmer surveys, and farm experiments. We simulated the summer maize population of farmers' yield level, attainable yield level and potential yield level by establishing three cultivation modes: traditional farming practices (FP), established high-yield and high-efficiency practices (HH) and super-high-yield practices (SH), and introduce the cultivation relying solely on the basic soil fertility (BSF) to reveal the impact of environmental and management factors on yield gap. We explored the driving factors causing observed variations of yield gaps through a quantitative analysis of several additional parameters that are commonly used to characterize the efficiency of the maize production process, including the contribution rates of dry matter and harvest index to grain yield, the radiation interception rate and the radiation conversion efficiency. Our results show that the total yield gap based on farmer surveys and crop models was 4.9 t ha1, accounting for 37% of the potential yield, of which 46% was exploitable. The total yield gap based on the farm experiments was 3.9 t ha1, accounting for 30% of the potential yield, of which 69% was exploitable. The grain yield of FP significantly positively correlated with the grain yield of BSF, HH and SH. The contribution rates of dry matter and harvest index to grain yield of FP treatment were 45.7% and 54.3%, respectively. With the increase of yield level, the contribution rate of dry matter increased and the contribution rate of harvest index decreased. In summary, we found a sizeable total yield gap in summer maize in the North China Plain, and a considerable part is exploitable. Optimizing inte-grated agronomic management has a great potential for closing the exploitable yield gap. Narrowing the yield gap requires a synergistic increase in the contribution rate of dry matter and harvest index to grain yield, but a substantial increase in dry matter is more important. At present, narrowing the exploitable yield gap requires synergistic improvement of radiation interception rate and radiation conversion efficiency to increase the dry matter of maize population. In the future, the regulation measures aiming at narrowing the unexploitable yield gap should further focus on improving the radiation conversion efficiency.