Communication of solar geoengineering science: Forms, examples, and explanation of skewing

被引:6
|
作者
Reynolds, Jesse L. [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Sch Law, Los Angeles, CA 90095 USA
[2] Univ Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands
来源
ANTHROPOCENE REVIEW | 2023年 / 10卷 / 02期
关键词
bias; climate change; geoengineering; science communication; solar radiation modification; CLIMATE; DISCOURSES;
D O I
10.1177/20530196221095569
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Although a judicious use of solar radiation modification (SRM, or solar geoengineering) appears able to reduce climate change, SRM would create risks of its own. How results and conclusions are conveyed is important. This article describes nine cases in which scientific articles and their official press releases communicate results inaccurately: by inappropriately comparing SRM with a reference world of non-elevated greenhouse gas concentrations; focusing on the residual climatic anomalies that SRM would not entirely eliminate; generalizing a predictably harmful assumed implementation regime to all possible SRM; or reporting conclusions that the paper does not substantiate. Notably, each of these cases unduly amplifies SRM's apparent risks and limitations. Collectively they may skew SRM communication and cause negative impacts on scientific assessments, news reporting, and policy discussions. The article suggests explanations for why SRM scientists and their official communicators sometimes inaccurately convey their results as well as how they and others should respond.
引用
收藏
页码:573 / 591
页数:19
相关论文
共 35 条
  • [1] An overview of the Earth system science of solar geoengineering
    Irvine, Peter J.
    Kravitz, Ben
    Lawrence, Mark G.
    Muri, Helene
    WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-CLIMATE CHANGE, 2016, 7 (06) : 815 - 833
  • [2] CLIMATE POLICY Social science research to inform solar geoengineering
    Aldy, Joseph E.
    Felgenhauer, Tyler
    Pizer, William A.
    Tavoni, Massimo
    Belaia, Mariia
    Borsuk, Mark E.
    Ghosh, Arunabha
    Heutel, Garth
    Heyen, Daniel
    Horton, Joshua
    Keith, David
    Merk, Christine
    Moreno-Cruz, Juan
    Reynolds, Jesse L.
    Ricke, Katharine
    Rickels, Wilfried
    Shayegh, Soheil
    Smith, Wake
    Tilmes, Simone
    Wagner, Gernot
    Wiener, Jonathan B.
    SCIENCE, 2021, 374 (6569) : 815 - 818
  • [3] Solar Geoengineering: Social Science, Legal, Ethical, and Economic Frameworks
    Flegal, Jane A.
    Hubert, Anna-Maria
    Morrow, David R.
    Moreno-Cruz, Juan B.
    ANNUAL REVIEW OF ENVIRONMENT AND RESOURCES, VOL 44, 2019, 44 : 399 - 423
  • [4] Conducting more inclusive solar geoengineering research: A feminist science framework
    Kravitz, Ben
    Sikka, Tina
    ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING E-NATURE AND SPACE, 2023, 6 (03) : 1636 - 1660
  • [5] Beyond solutionist science for the Anthropocene: To navigate the contentious atmosphere of solar geoengineering
    Asayama, Shinichiro
    Sugiyama, Masahiro
    Ishii, Atsushi
    Kosugi, Takanobu
    ANTHROPOCENE REVIEW, 2019, 6 (1-2): : 19 - 37
  • [6] Science Communication in Kinesiology: Examples for Engaging Students
    Elmer, Steven J.
    KINESIOLOGY REVIEW, 2024, 13 (04) : 506 - 515
  • [7] Nonlinear Unidimensionality in Communication Science: Tests, Examples, and Implications
    Keating, David M.
    Boster, Franklin J.
    COMMUNICATION RESEARCH REPORTS, 2019, 36 (01) : 67 - 77
  • [8] Geoengineering and Climate Change Polarization: Testing a Two-Channel Model of Science Communication
    Kahan, Dan M.
    Jenkins-Smith, Hank
    Tarantola, Tor
    Silva, Carol L.
    Braman, Donald
    ANNALS OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF POLITICAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCE, 2015, 658 (01): : 192 - 222
  • [9] On New Forms of Science Communication and Communication in Science: A Videographic Approach to Visuality in Science Slams and Academic Group Talk
    Wilke, Rene
    Hill, Miira
    QUALITATIVE INQUIRY, 2019, 25 (04) : 363 - 378
  • [10] Science Communication as a Collective Intelligence Endeavor: A Manifesto and Examples for Implementation
    Holford, Dawn
    Fasce, Angelo
    Tapper, Katy
    Demko, Miso
    Lewandowsky, Stephan
    Hahn, Ulrike
    Abels, Christoph M.
    Al-Rawi, Ahmed
    Alladin, Sameer
    Boender, T. Sonia
    Bruns, Hendrik
    Fischer, Helen
    Gilde, Christian
    Hanel, Paul H. P.
    Herzog, Stefan M.
    Kause, Astrid
    Lehmann, Sune
    Nurse, Matthew S.
    Orr, Caroline
    Pescetelli, Niccolo
    Petrescu, Maria
    Sah, Sunita
    Schmid, Philipp
    Sirota, Miroslav
    Wulf, Marlene
    SCIENCE COMMUNICATION, 2023, 45 (04) : 539 - 554