Do group agents have free will?

被引:0
|
作者
List, Christian [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Munich Ctr Math Philosophy, Munich, Germany
[2] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Munich Ctr Math Philosophy, Geschwister Scholl Pl 1, D-80539 Munich, Germany
关键词
Group agency; free will; compatibilism; libertarianism; corporate responsibility; RESPONSIBILITY; EXCLUSION;
D O I
10.1080/0020174X.2023.2218721
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
It is common to ascribe agency to some organized collectives, such as corporations, courts, and states, and to treat them as loci of responsibility, over and above their individual members. But since responsibility is often assumed to require free will, should we also think that group agents have free will? Surprisingly, the literature contains very few in-depth discussions of this question. The most extensive defence of corporate free will that I am aware of (Hess [2014], "The Free Will of Corporations (and Other Collectives)", Philosophical Studies 168 (1): 241-260) rests on a compatibilist understanding which takes reasons-responsiveness and acting from one's own 'actional springs' as key conditions for free will but says little about a condition that free-will libertarians emphasize: the possibility of doing otherwise. In this paper, I will argue that group agents can have free will not only in a (less demanding) compatibilist sense, but also in a recognizably libertarian sense, which includes the possibility of doing otherwise. In developing this account of corporate free will, I will bring together recent work on group agency and recent work on free will.
引用
收藏
页数:28
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] DO WE HAVE FREE WILL?
    Brooks, Michael
    [J]. NEW SCIENTIST, 2016, 231 (3089) : 35 - 35
  • [2] Do we have free will?
    Churchland, Patricia
    Kolb, Rocky
    Miller, Richard
    Gott, J. Richard
    Gazzaniga, Michael
    [J]. NEW SCIENTIST, 2006, 192 (2578) : 42 - 45
  • [3] Do animals have free will?
    Steward, Helen
    [J]. TPM-THE PHILOSOPHERS MAGAZINE, 2015, (68): : 43 - 48
  • [4] Do we have free will.
    Libet, B
    [J]. FASEB JOURNAL, 1998, 12 (04): : A137 - A137
  • [5] Do fruit flies have free will?
    Iredale, Mathew
    Midgley, Mary
    [J]. TPM-THE PHILOSOPHERS MAGAZINE, 2011, (53): : 32 - 45
  • [6] Do Railroads Have a Free Ride?
    Yang, Jia Lynn
    [J]. FORTUNE, 2009, 160 (04) : 22 - 22
  • [7] Do Group Persons have Emotions - or Should They?
    Szanto, Thomas
    [J]. ANALYTIC AND CONTINENTAL PHILOSOPHY: METHODS AND PERSPECTIVES, 2016, 23 : 261 - 276
  • [8] Do most antihypertensive agents have a sympatholytic action?
    De Champlain J.
    [J]. Current Hypertension Reports, 2001, 3 (4) : 305 - 313
  • [9] Do we have free will? Ask a physicist
    不详
    [J]. NEW SCIENTIST, 2007, 195 (2615) : 5 - 5
  • [10] Personalizing Dialogue Agents: I have a dog, do you have pets too?
    Zhang, Saizheng
    Dinan, Emily
    Urbanek, Jack
    Szlam, Arthur
    Kiela, Douwe
    Weston, Jason
    [J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE 56TH ANNUAL MEETING OF THE ASSOCIATION FOR COMPUTATIONAL LINGUISTICS (ACL), VOL 1, 2018, : 2204 - 2213