Best Practice Recommendations for Dysphagia Management in Intensive Care Unit (ICU): A Delphi Study from Multidisciplinary Experts in Turkey

被引:2
|
作者
Umay, Ebru [1 ]
Eyigor, Sibel [2 ]
Demirag, Kubilay [3 ]
Kaymak Karatas, Gulcin [4 ]
Gundogdu, Ibrahim [1 ]
Giray, Esra [5 ]
Panpalli Ates, Mehlika [6 ]
Gonenli Kocer, Bilge [6 ]
Gurcay, Eda [7 ]
Unlu, Zeliha [8 ]
Bengisu, Serkan [9 ]
Karaahmet, Fatih [10 ]
Bagcier, Fatih [11 ]
Vural, Meltem [12 ]
Aydeniz, Banu [12 ]
Kullukcu, Humeyra [13 ]
Oztekin, Fevzi [6 ]
Alicura, Sibel [14 ]
Uz, Cuma [1 ]
Barmak, Elife [15 ]
Uzunkulaoglu, Aslihan [1 ]
Adiguzel, Emre [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Hlth Sci Turkey, Ankara Etlik City Phys Med & Rehabil Hosp, Halil Sezai Erkut St 5, TR-06170 Yenimahalle, Ankara, Turkiye
[2] Ege Univ, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Izmir, Turkiye
[3] Ege Univ, Dept Anesthesiol & Reanimat, Izmir, Turkiye
[4] Gazi Univ, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Ankara, Turkiye
[5] Univ Hlth Sci Turkey, Fatih Sultan Mehmet Training & Res Hosp, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Istanbul, Turkiye
[6] Univ Hlth Sci Turkey, Ankara Etlik City Hosp, Dept Neurol, Ankara, Turkiye
[7] Univ Hlth Sci Turkey, Gaziler Phys Med & Rehabil Training & Res Hosp, Ankara, Turkiye
[8] Celal Bayar Univ, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Manisa, Turkiye
[9] Fenerbahce Univ, Dept Speech & Language Therapy, Istanbul, Turkiye
[10] Medicana Int Ankara Hosp, Dept Gastroenterol, Ankara, Turkiye
[11] Basaksehir Cam Sakura Hosp, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Istanbul, Turkiye
[12] Univ Hlth Sci, Bakirkoy Dr Sadi Konuk Training & Res Hosp, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Istanbul, Turkiye
[13] Ankara Med Pk Hosp, Dept Neurosurg, Ankara, Turkiye
[14] Univ Hlth Sci Turkey, Ankara Etlik City Hosp, Dept Otolaryngol Head & Neck Surg, Ankara, Turkiye
[15] Univ Hlth Sci Turkey, Ankara Etlik City Hosp, Dept Speech & Language Therapy, Ankara, Turkiye
关键词
Dysphagia; Intensive care unit; Management; Diagnosis; Rehabilitation; Follow-up; ASPIRATION; KAPPA;
D O I
10.1007/s00455-023-10606-w
中图分类号
R76 [耳鼻咽喉科学];
学科分类号
100213 ;
摘要
There is no study about all aspects of oropharyngoesophageal (OPE) dysphagia from diagnosis to follow-up in a multidisciplinary manner in the world. In order to close this gap, we aimed to create a recommendation study that can be used in clinical practice, addressing all aspects of dysphagia in the ICU in detail with the opinion of experienced multidisciplinary experts. This recommendation paper was generated by a multidisciplinary team, using the seven-step process and a three-modified Delphi round via e-mail. Firstly, 15 open-ended questions were created, and then detailed recommendations including general principles, management, diagnosis, rehabilitation, and follow-up were created with the answers from these questions, Each recommendation item was voted on by the experts as overall consensus (strong recommendation), approaching consensus (weak recommendation), and divergent consensus (not recommended).In the first Delphi round, a questionnaire consisting of 413 items evaluated with a scale of 0-10 was prepared from the opinions and suggestions given to 15 open-ended questions. In the second Delphi round, 55.4% were accepted and revised suggestions were created. At the end of the third Delphi round, the revised suggestion form was approved again and the final proposals containing 133 items were created. This study includes comprehensive and detailed recommendations, including a broad perspective from diagnosis to treatment and follow-up, as detailed as possible, for management of dysphagia in patients with both oropharyngeal- and esophageal-dysphagia in ICU.
引用
收藏
页码:241 / 254
页数:14
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Best Practice Recommendations for Dysphagia Management in Intensive Care Unit (ICU): A Delphi Study from Multidisciplinary Experts in Turkey
    Ebru Umay
    Sibel Eyigor
    Kubilay Demirag
    Gulcin Kaymak Karatas
    Ibrahim Gundogdu
    Esra Giray
    Mehlika Panpalli Ates
    Bilge Gonenli Kocer
    Eda Gurcay
    Zeliha Unlu
    Serkan Bengisu
    Fatih Karaahmet
    Fatih Bagcier
    Meltem Vural
    Banu Aydeniz
    Humeyra Kullukcu
    Fevzi Oztekin
    Sibel Alicura
    Cuma Uz
    Elife Barmak
    Aslihan Uzunkulaoglu
    Emre Adiguzel
    Dysphagia, 2024, 39 : 241 - 254
  • [2] Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Patients with Dysphagia: A Delphi-Based Consensus Study of Experts in Turkey-Part II: Rehabilitation
    Umay, Ebru
    Eyigor, Sibel
    Ertekin, Cumhur
    Unlu, Zeliha
    Selcuk, Barin
    Bahat, Gulistan
    Karahan, Ali Yavuz
    Secil, Yaprak
    Gurcay, Eda
    Kiylioglu, Nefati
    Keles, Betul Yavuz
    Giray, Esra
    Tikiz, Canan
    Gezer, Ilknur Albayrak
    Yaliman, Ayse
    Sen, Ekin Ilke
    Vural, Meltem
    Saylam, Guleser
    Akaltun, Mazlum Serdar
    Sari, Aylin
    Alicura, Sibel
    Karaahmet, Fatih
    Inanir, Murat
    Demirhan, Aylin
    Aydeniz, Banu
    Bilgilisoy, Meral
    Yuksel, Arif
    Ozcete, Zeynep Alev
    Calik, Yalkin
    Alemdaroglu, Ebru
    Keskin, Dilek
    Sahin, Sevnaz
    Oztekin, Mehmet Fevzi
    Sezgin, Baha
    Karaahmet, Ozgur
    DYSPHAGIA, 2021, 36 (05) : 800 - 820
  • [3] Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Patients with Dysphagia: A Delphi-Based Consensus Study of Experts in Turkey-Part II: Rehabilitation
    Ebru Umay
    Sibel Eyigor
    Cumhur Ertekin
    Zeliha Unlu
    Barin Selcuk
    Gulistan Bahat
    Ali Yavuz Karahan
    Yaprak Secil
    Eda Gurcay
    Nefati Kıylioglu
    Betul Yavuz Keles
    Esra Giray
    Canan Tikiz
    Ilknur Albayrak Gezer
    Ayse Yalıman
    Ekin Ilke Sen
    Meltem Vural
    Guleser Saylam
    Mazlum Serdar Akaltun
    Aylin Sari
    Sibel Alicura
    Fatih Karaahmet
    Murat Inanir
    Aylin Demirhan
    Banu Aydeniz
    Meral Bilgilisoy
    Arif Yuksel
    Zeynep Alev Ozcete
    Yalkın Calik
    Ebru Alemdaroglu
    Dilek Keskin
    Sevnaz Sahin
    Mehmet Fevzi Oztekin
    Baha Sezgin
    Ozgur Karaahmet
    Dysphagia, 2021, 36 : 800 - 820
  • [4] Pediatric dysphagia overview: best practice recommendation study by multidisciplinary experts
    Umay, Ebru
    Eyigor, Sibel
    Giray, Esra
    Saygi, Evrim Karadag
    Karadag, Bulent
    Kocaaslan, Nihal Durmus
    Yuksel, Deniz
    Demir, Arzu Meltem
    Tutar, Engin
    Tikiz, Canan
    Gurcay, Eda
    Unlu, Zeliha
    Celik, Pelin
    Akyuz, Ece Unlu
    Mengu, Guven
    Bengisu, Serkan
    Alicura, Sibel
    Unver, Necati
    Yekteusaklari, Nida
    Uz, Cuma
    Uytun, Merve Cikili
    Bagcier, Fatih
    Tarihci, Elif
    Akaltun, Mazlum Serdar
    Sucakli, Iclal Ayranci
    Cankurtaran, Damla
    Aykin, Zeynep
    Aydin, Resa
    Nazli, Fatma
    WORLD JOURNAL OF PEDIATRICS, 2022, 18 (11) : 715 - 724
  • [5] Pediatric dysphagia overview: best practice recommendation study by multidisciplinary experts
    Ebru Umay
    Sibel Eyigor
    Esra Giray
    Evrim Karadag Saygi
    Bulent Karadag
    Nihal Durmus Kocaaslan
    Deniz Yuksel
    Arzu Meltem Demir
    Engin Tutar
    Canan Tikiz
    Eda Gurcay
    Zeliha Unlu
    Pelin Celik
    Ece Unlu Akyuz
    Guven Mengu
    Serkan Bengisu
    Sibel Alicura
    Necati Unver
    Nida Yekteusaklari
    Cuma Uz
    Merve Cikili Uytun
    Fatih Bagcier
    Elif Tarihci
    Mazlum Serdar Akaltun
    Iclal Ayranci Sucakli
    Damla Cankurtaran
    Zeynep Aykın
    Resa Aydın
    Fatma Nazli
    World Journal of Pediatrics, 2022, 18 : 715 - 724
  • [6] Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Patients with Dysphagia: A Delphi-Based Consensus Study of Experts in Turkey-Part I: Management, Diagnosis, and Follow-up
    Umay, Ebru
    Eyigor, Sibel
    Ertekin, Cumhur
    Unlu, Zeliha
    Selcuk, Barin
    Bahat, Gulistan
    Karahan, Ali Yavuz
    Secil, Yaprak
    Gurcay, Eda
    Kiylioglu, Nefati
    Keles, Betul Yavuz
    Giray, Esra
    Tikiz, Canan
    Gezer, Ilknur Albayrak
    Yaliman, Ayse
    Sen, Ekin Ilke
    Vural, Meltem
    Saylam, Guleser
    Akaltun, Mazlum Serdar
    Sari, Aylin
    Alicura, Sibel
    Karaahmet, Fatih
    Inanir, Murat
    Demirhan, Aylin
    Aydeniz, Banu
    Bilgilisoy, Meral
    Yuksel, Arif
    Ozcete, Zeynep Alev
    Calik, Yalkin
    Alemdaroglu, Ebru
    Keskin, Dilek
    Sahin, Sevnaz
    Oztekin, Mehmet Fevzi
    Sezgin, Baha
    Karaahmet, Ozgur
    Bengisu, Serkan
    Gokler, Tanu Yalcin
    Mercimekci, Serdar
    DYSPHAGIA, 2022, 37 (02) : 217 - 236
  • [7] Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Patients with Dysphagia: A Delphi-Based Consensus Study of Experts in Turkey-Part I: Management, Diagnosis, and Follow-up
    Ebru Umay
    Sibel Eyigor
    Cumhur Ertekin
    Zeliha Unlu
    Barin Selcuk
    Gulistan Bahat
    Ali Yavuz Karahan
    Yaprak Secil
    Eda Gurcay
    Nefati Kıylioglu
    Betul Yavuz Keles
    Esra Giray
    Canan Tikiz
    Ilknur Albayrak Gezer
    Ayse Yalıman
    Ekin Ilke Sen
    Meltem Vural
    Guleser Saylam
    Mazlum Serdar Akaltun
    Aylin Sari
    Sibel Alicura
    Fatih Karaahmet
    Murat Inanir
    Aylin Demirhan
    Banu Aydeniz
    Meral Bilgilisoy
    Arif Yuksel
    Zeynep Alev Ozcete
    Yalkın Calik
    Ebru Alemdaroglu
    Dilek Keskin
    Sevnaz Sahin
    Mehmet Fevzi Oztekin
    Baha Sezgin
    Ozgur Karaahmet
    Serkan Bengisu
    Tanu Yalcin Gokler
    Serdar Mercimekci
    Dysphagia, 2022, 37 : 217 - 236
  • [8] Pain Management Strategies in Intensive Care Unit: Challenges and Best Practice
    Zakeri, Habib
    Mahtosh, Pantea
    Radmehr, Mohammad
    Rahbani, Roohollah
    Montazeri, Leala
    Moalemi, Saba
    Mahdiyar, Parisa
    Hemati, Farnaz
    Karimi, Aliasghar
    GALEN MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2024, 13
  • [9] Experts' recommendations: Stroke management in the intensive care unit. Pediatric specificities (excluding neonates)
    Kossorotoff, M.
    Meyer, P.
    Lebas, A.
    Chabrier, S.
    REVUE NEUROLOGIQUE, 2012, 168 (6-7) : 527 - 532
  • [10] Specific treatment for intracerebral hemorrhage. Experts' recommendations: Stroke management in the intensive care unit
    de Bustos, E. Medeiros
    Moulin, T.
    REVUE NEUROLOGIQUE, 2012, 168 (6-7) : 522 - 526