PRINCIPLES OF LEGAL ZONING IN THE JUDICIAL PRACTICE**

被引:0
|
作者
V. Gudz, Tatyana [1 ]
V. Soldatova, Larisa [2 ]
V. Samolovskikh, Natalia [3 ]
机构
[1] HSE Univ, Fac Urban & Reg Dev, Vysokovsky Grad Sch Urbanism, 13-4 Myasnitskaya ul, Moscow 109028, Russia
[2] HSE Univ, Sch Publ Law, Fac Law, 3 Bolshoi Trekhsvyatitelskii per, Moscow 109028, Russia
[3] Ural State Law Univ, 21 Komsomolskaya ul, Ekaterinburg 620137, Russia
来源
关键词
Principles legal zoning rules; of land use jurisprudence law; making; COURTS; FRANCE;
D O I
10.52468/2542-1514.2023.7
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
The present article deals with the study of the principles of legal zoning through their disclo-sure in judicial practice. The topic is underdeveloped. The purpose of the study is to identify the role of judicial practice in the legal regulation of urban zoning, as well as the impact on law enforcement and law-making activities in this area. The authors propose to use a classification of principles of legal zoning by level of their action (general legal principles, principles of sec-toral legislation and special principles) and revealing their content through the analysis of ju-dicial practice materials. In addition to general scientific methods, the comparative legal, for-mal legal and interpretation methods made it possible to achieve better results. The analysis was conducted with respect to judicial acts adopted by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, as well as judicial acts of courts of general jurisdiction and arbitra-tion courts of cassation and appeal instances. More than 150 judicial acts in several catego-ries were examined in total: - Challenging general plan and land use rules as a legal act; - Challenging the refusal to grant permission for permitted use or challenging the granted permission for permitted use; - Challenging the refusal to grant permission to deviate from the maximum parameters of permitted construction, reconstruction of the object of construction or challenging the per-mission to deviate from the maximum parameters of permitted construction. According to the results of the study it is possible to identify several ways of working with the principles of legal zoning: - direct quotation and application, if it is a principle of sectoral legislation, which is en-shrined, for example, in the Urban Planning Code of the Russian Federation; - disclosure of content without precise formulation, for example, the principle of protection of previously arisen rights of right holders of land plots when changing legal zoning, which is not directly mentioned in judicial acts, but is disclosed through references to current legislation; - the formation of new principles not enshrined in the current legal acts, such as the prin-ciple of primacy of the master plan or the principle of belonging of a land plot only to one territorial zone. Approaches and legal provisions, broadcasted by judicial practice, are reflected in the law enforcement and law-making activities of local self-government bodies. The authors draw attention to the fact that local self-governing bodies assess and take into account the emerging judicial practice in different ways. This fact is confirmed by the current editions of the rules of land use and development in different Russian cities.
引用
收藏
页码:105 / 115
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Legal Principles, Constitutional Principles, and Judicial Review
    Zhou, Han-Ru
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF COMPARATIVE LAW, 2019, 67 (04): : 889 - 930
  • [2] REFERENDUM ZONING - LEGAL DOCTRINE AND PRACTICE
    ROSENBERG, RH
    [J]. UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI LAW REVIEW, 1984, 53 (02) : 381 - 433
  • [3] Research on the Judicial Application of Legal Principles
    Lin, Feifei
    [J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2018 8TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON SOCIAL SCIENCE AND EDUCATION RESEARCH (SSER 2018), 2018, 238 : 594 - 598
  • [4] Corruption, Legal Modernisation and Judicial Practice in Afghanistan
    De Lauri, Antonio
    [J]. ASIAN STUDIES REVIEW, 2013, 37 (04): : 527 - 545
  • [5] Impact of the Legal Doctrine on Lawmaking and Judicial Practice in Russia
    Anisimov, Aleksey
    Ryzhenkov, Anatoliy
    Sokolskaya, Liudmila
    [J]. ARCHIV FUR RECHTS- UND SOZIALPHILOSOPHIE, 2019, 105 (04): : 453 - 470
  • [6] ZONING - GUIDE TO JUDICIAL REVIEW
    FEILER, MH
    [J]. JOURNAL OF URBAN LAW, 1970, 47 (02): : 319 - 343
  • [7] Legal Certainty in Veterinary Practice. Judicial Veterinary Medicine for Everyday Practice
    Demattio, Lukas
    [J]. TIERAERZTLICHE PRAXIS AUSGABE GROSSTIERE NUTZTIERE, 2021, 49 (05): : 363 - +
  • [8] CRITERIA FOR THE NORMATIVITY OF INTERPRETATIVE LEGAL ACTS IN RUSSIAN JUDICIAL PRACTICE
    Timoshina, Elena, V
    Kraevsky, Arseny A.
    [J]. PRAVOPRIMENENIE-LAW ENFORCEMENT REVIEW, 2022, 6 (04): : 220 - 243
  • [9] The procedural form of judicial conciliation procedure: Concept, legal nature, principles
    Mikhailova, Ekaterina V.
    Novikov, Nikolay A.
    [J]. VESTNIK OF SAINT PETERSBURG UNIVERSITY-LAW-VESTNIK SANKT-PETERBURGSKOGO UNIVERSITETA-PRAVO, 2023, 14 (04): : 969 - 986
  • [10] THE CONCEPT OF CONSTITUTIONAL IDENTITY AS A LEGAL ARGUMENT IN CONSTITUTIONAL JUDICIAL PRACTICE
    Kucherenko, Petr
    Klochko, Elena
    [J]. RUSSIAN LAW JOURNAL, 2019, 7 (04) : 99 - 124