Reading Campeanu through Lewin: A contribution to the political history of Stalinism

Owing to various reasons, Stalinism still represents, according to this essay, a fertile intellectual topic. Therefore, my aim here is to offer a reading of Pavel Campeanu's works on Stalinism - a relatively unknown Romanian Marxist - through the social history of the Soviet Union in general and of Stalinism in particular advanced by Moshe Lewin. The argumentation advances by taking into account the overall historical frame of the debate (Eastern and Western Marxism during the Cold War) and by stressing some key issues like primitive accumulation, legitimacy, a certain overstretching of the concept of Stalinism and, finally, the issue of totalitarianism. The stake of the essay resides in claiming that Campeanu's analyses of Stalinism, original and convincing as they are, may favor, in the above-mentioned issues, and regardless the author's intentions, interpretations belonging to or deriving from the totalitarian school of Cold War and Soviet Studies.