Subtask-Based Usability Evaluation of Control Interfaces for Teleoperated Excavation Tasks

This study aims to experimentally determine the most suitable control interface for different subtasks in the teleoperation of construction robots in a simulation environment. We compare a conventional lever-based rate control interface ("Rate-lever") with two alternative methods: rate control ("Rate-3D") and position control ("Position-3D"), both using a 3D positional input device. In the experiments, participants operated a construction machine in a virtual environment and evaluated the control interfaces across three tasks: sagittal plane excavation, turning, and continuous operation. The results revealed that "Position-3D" outperformed others for sagittal excavation, while both "Rate-lever" and "Rate-3D" were more effective for turning. Notably, "Position-3D" and "Rate-3D" can be implemented on the same input device and are easily integrated. This feature offers the possibility of a hybrid-type interface suitable for operators to obtain optimized performance in sagittal and horizontal tasks.