Improved Mesenchymal Stem Cell Viability in High-Stiffness, Translational Cartilage Matrix Hydrogels

Scaffolds made from cartilage extracellular matrix are promising materials for articular cartilage repair, attributed to their intrinsic bioactivity that may promote chondrogenesis. While several cartilage matrix-based scaffolds have supported chondrogenesis in vitro and/or in vivo, it remains a challenge to balance the biological response (e.g., chondroinductivity) with structural (e.g., robust mechanical performance, >1 MPa in compressive stiffness) and translational (e.g., ease of surgical implantation) considerations. Few studies have evaluated encapsulated cell viability within high-stiffness (>1 MPa) hydrogels. We previously fabricated one formulation of a high-stiffness (>3 MPa) pentenoate-functionalized, solubilized, devitalized cartilage (PSDVC) hydrogel that possessed an injectable, paste-like precursor for easy surgical application. In the current study, the characterization of the PSDVC material was expanded by varying the degree of functionalization (i.e., 0.45-1.09 mmol/g) and amount of crosslinker, dithiothreitol (DTT), to improve the reproducibility of the high compressive moduli and evaluate the viability of encapsulated human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (hBMSCs) in high-stiffness cartilage matrix hydrogels. Prior to crosslinking, specific formulations functionalized with 0.80 mmol/g or less of pentenoate groups retained a paste-like precursor rheology. After crosslinking, these formulations produced hydrogels with greater than 1 MPa compressive stiffness. However, hBMSCs encapsulated in PSDVC hydrogels with lower functionalization (i.e., 0.57 mmol/g, no crosslinker) had a higher stiffness (i.e., 1.4 MPa) but the lowest viability of encapsulated hBMSCs (i.e., 5%). The middle PSDVC functionalization (i.e., 0.70 mmol/g) with DTT (i.e., 0.50 mmol thiols/g) demonstrated high cell viability (77%), high mechanical performance (1.65 MPa, 31% failure strain), and translational features (i.e., paste-like precursor, 1.5 min crosslinking time). For future evaluations of PSDVC hydrogels in cartilage repair, a middle functionalization (i.e., 0.70-0.80 mmol/g) with the addition of a crosslinker (i.e., 0.50 mmol thiols/g) had a desirable balance of high mechanical performance (i.e., >1 MPa compressive stiffness), high viability, and paste-like precursor for surgical translation.