Do linear clearings in boreal peatlands recover? Comparing taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional plant diversity

Land-use changes and anthropogenic disturbances are major threats to biodiversity, affecting ecosystem function and recovery. In boreal Alberta, Canada, petroleum development has led to extensive landscape fragmentation, notably through linear clearings created for seismic exploration that remove surface vegetation and microtopography. Despite partial recovery on forested seismic lines, peatland recovery is often arrested, impacting wildlife and carbon dynamics. Restoration efforts employ silviculture techniques to create microtopography and foster tree growth, but the efficacy of restoration treatments in restoring peatland plant diversity remains uncertain. We compared taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional diversity of understory plant communities across treated and untreated seismic lines, alongside reference sites in treed bogs and fens. Treated lines generally had a twofold increase in plant height, leaf dry matter content, and foliar nitrogen and phosphorus contents compared to reference sites. In bogs, treated lines differed from reference conditions driven by increases in herbaceous taxa, while fens displayed disparities mainly in taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity. Differential responses of bogs and fens underline the necessity for tailored management strategies. Changes in plant diversity away from restoration targets have implications for ecosystem recovery, emphasizing the importance of long-term monitoring to evaluate the effectiveness of silviculture techniques in restoring boreal peatland plant communities.