Depth-wise multiparametric assessment of articular cartilage layers with single-sided NMR

Articular cartilage (AC) is a specialized connective tissue that covers the ends of long bones and facilitates the load-bearing of joints. It consists of chondrocytes distributed throughout an extracellular matrix and organized into three zones: superficial, middle, and deep. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques can be used to characterize this layered structure. In this study, devoted to a better understanding of the NMR response of this complex tissue, 20 specimens excised from femoral and tibial cartilage of bovine samples were analyzed by the low-field single-sided NMR-MOUSE-PM10. A multiparametric depth-wise analysis was performed to characterize the laminar structure of AC and investigate the origin of the NMR dependence on depth. The depth dependence of the single parameters T1, T2, and D has been described in literature, but their simultaneous measurement has not been fully exploited yet, as well as the extent of their variability. A novel parameter, alpha, evaluated by applying a double-quantum-like sequence, has been measured. The significant decrease in T1, T2, and D from the middle to the deep zone is consistent with depth-dependent composition and structure changes of the complex matrix of fibers confining and interacting with water. The alpha parameter appears to be a robust marker of the layered structure with a well-reproducible monotonic trend across the zones. The discrimination of cartilage zones was reinforced by a multivariate principal component analysis statistical analysis. The large number of samples allowed for the identification of the smallest number of parameters or their combination able to classify samples. The first two components clustered the data according to the different zones, highlighting the sensitivity of the NMR parameters to the structural and compositional variations of AC. Using two parameters, the best result was obtained by considering T1 and alpha. Single-sided NMR devices, portable and low-cost, provide information on NMR parameters related to tissue composition and structure.