Microplastic (MP) pollution in the aquatic environment is widespread, with a significant fraction of these particles originating from municipal wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluents. Whereas membrane filtration processes are touted as an effective MP removal strategy, the rejection of irregularly-shaped plastic particles, similar to those found in WWTPs, is poorly understood. Here, we characterize the filtration of irregularly-shaped MP particles (similar to 10 mu m) through Durapore (R) microfiltration membranes (0.45 and 5 mu m pore sizes). These particles were produced via ball-milling/sieving processes from a fluorescent polyethylene feedstock, enabling particle concentrations to be quantified using a standard fluorometric plate reader. Permeate samples from the 0.45 mu m membrane exhibited low fluorescent intensities relative to feed samples, implying minimal MP transmission. Conversely, appreciable MP transmission through the 5 mu m membrane was noted, with sizable MPs (similar to 2-7 mu m) found in the permeate. This transmission was exacerbated at higher fluxes which emphasizes how operating conditions can govern MP retention. Post-filtration analyses demonstrated that particle capture occurred largely at the feed-membrane interface, where greater MP intrusion into the membrane was seen at the larger pore size. These results reaffirm the importance of choosing an appropriate membrane/membrane pore size and operating conditions to maximize MP retention in WWTPs.