Effects of night-float shifts on cognitive function among radiology residents

BackgroundMany radiology programs utilize a night-float system to mitigate the effects of fatigue, improve patient care, and provide faster report turnaround times. Prior studies have demonstrated an increase in discrepancy rates during night-float shifts.ObjectivesThis study was performed to examine the effects of night-float shift work on radiology resident cognition. We hypothesized that there would be diminished cognitive function on testing following night-float shifts when compared to testing following day shifts.MethodsDiagnostic radiology residents in their second to fifth years of residency at a single institution were recruited to participate in this pilot study. Cognitive function was evaluated using the Lumosity Neurocognitive Performance Tests (NCPT), standardized performance tests that provide real-time, objective measurements of cognitive function. Study participants completed the NCPT in 5 sessions following 5 consecutive day shifts to evaluate their baseline cognitive function. The tests were re-administered at the end of consecutive night-float shifts to assess for any changes. Sleep was objectively monitored using actigraphy devices worn around the wrist during all study weeks. Descriptive and summary statistics were performed.Results23 prospectively recruited diagnostic radiology residents working night-float shifts took a mean 13.6 (+/- 5.1) neurocognitive performance tests during the study period. There was a statistically significant decline in 2 of the 6 cognitive tests administered, signifying a decrease in attention, speed, and complex reasoning ability. Night-float shifts were significantly longer than the day shifts and associated with a significantly higher study volume and cross-sectional study volume. Fitbit data demonstrated that there were no significant differences in level of activity while awake. However, participants slept significantly longer during day shifts.ConclusionsA sample of 23 radiology residents working night-float shifts demonstrated declines in attention, speed, and complex reasoning ability following sequential administration of standardized neurocognitive performance tests. While the sample size is small, these findings demonstrate the potential deleterious effects of night-float shift work and provide evidence to support further inquiry into this phenomenon.