What "evidence" does Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) refer to?

被引:0
|
作者
Torres, Karina Ordonez [1 ]
Barrera, Jorge Martinez [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Finis Terrae, Fac Med, Inst Bioet, Santiago, Chile
[2] Univ Gabriela Mistral, Fac Ciencias Sociales Jurid & Human, Santiago, Chile
关键词
evidence-based medicine; epistemology; evidence;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
This article examines the use of the concept of "evidence" in the current movement known as "Evidence-Based Medicine" (EBM). The article includes some historical milestones of the concept, in which Aristotle, Andr & eacute; Lalande and Michel Foucault are the main references. Then, the process through which EBM was born is reviewed, going through Cochrane, Guyatt, Sackett and Woolf. It is explained that EBM understands evidence as facts, where controlled and randomized clinical studies, as well as systematic reviews, are the most appropriate means to obtain evidence. We propose that EBM may not be aware that the concept of "evidence" used is crypto-normative, which makes this concept contain a strong axiological load. The article does not intend to simply dismiss the concept of "evidence", but rather to review its univocality and open it to an analogous understanding that could improve clinical practices and the theoretical scope that serve as their foundation. A central part of the arguments used in this paper consists of reviewing the supposed epistemic neutrality of EBM, which is a movement in formation that requires various adjustments. Among them, an in-depth review of the concept that gives it its name and meaning, for the benefit of the generators and users of EBM (clinicians and patients).
引用
收藏
页码:245 / 252
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Evidence-based medicine (EBM)
    Jost, WH
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY, 2001, 248 : S1 - S2
  • [2] Evidence-based medicine (EBM)
    Wolfgang H. Jost
    [J]. Journal of Neurology, 2001, 248 (Suppl 1) : I1 - I2
  • [3] Evidence-based medicine (EBM) ...
    Vennin, P
    [J]. BULLETIN DU CANCER, 1998, 85 (04) : 358 - 359
  • [4] 2023 Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) Update
    Huh, Jeannie
    Louis-Ugbo Sr, John
    Hembree, Walter C.
    Wagner, Emilio
    Chodos, Marc D.
    Zingas, Christopher N.
    Vopat, Bryan G.
    Dalal, Aliasgar
    Alhadhoud, Meshal
    Sherman, Thomas I.
    [J]. FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL, 2024, 45 (05) : 547 - 554
  • [5] Evidence-based medicine (EBM) in trauma surgery
    Bauwens, K.
    Stengel, D.
    Ekkernkamp, A.
    [J]. TRAUMA UND BERUFSKRANKHEIT, 2008, 10 : 208 - 211
  • [6] Value and limits of evidence-based medicine (EBM)
    Pagliaro, Luigi
    [J]. PORTAL HYPERTENSION IV, 2006, : 345 - 355
  • [7] Strengths and weaknesses of evidence-based medicine (EBM)
    Davidson, M.
    [J]. EUROPEAN PSYCHIATRY, 2008, 23 : S6 - S6
  • [8] What “Evidence” in Evidence-Based Medicine?
    Carlo Martini
    [J]. Topoi, 2021, 40 : 299 - 305
  • [9] What evidence in Evidence-Based Medicine?
    Worrall, J
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2002, 69 (03) : S316 - S330
  • [10] What "Evidence" in Evidence-Based Medicine?
    Martini, Carlo
    [J]. TOPOI-AN INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF PHILOSOPHY, 2021, 40 (02): : 299 - 305