A Two-Year Study of Bioorganic Fertilizer on the Content of Pb and As in Brown Rice and Rice Yield in a Contaminated Paddy Field

Bioorganic fertilizer (BOF) represents favorable potential for agricultural production, but the safe and residual effects of BOF application in heavy-metal-contaminated soils still remain unclear. A two-year field experiment of four rice-growing cycles were conducted to study the effects of the one-time addition of BOF (low and high dosages, 0.45 and 0.9 kg/m2, namely, BOF1 and BOF2, respectively) on the lead (Pb) and arsenic (As) accumulations in brown rice, rice yield, and soil properties in an acidic and Pb-As-contaminated paddy field. The results show that BOF application enhanced the rice yields by 7.9-25.5% and increased the soil pH, organic carbon contents, and fluorescein diacetate hydrolase activity in the former two rice-growing cycles, while these attributes declined gradually and were not significant in the last two cycles. The soil bulk density decreased marginally due to the BOF. Furthermore, the BOF1 treatment barely affected the rice Pb and As concentrations during all cycles, whereas the BOF2 treatment clearly increased the Pb concentrations in brown rice, exceeding the food quality standard limit of 0.2 mg/kg in the last three cycles, and slightly increased the rice As in the former three cycles. The BOF effects on Pb and As in brown rice were due to the changes in the available soil Pb and As, respectively. Our results indicate that a one-time application of BOF could ameliorate the soil conditions of rice growth in two rice-growing cycles, while the high-dose BOF seemed undesirable in toxic-metal-contaminated soils. BOF application at the rate of 0.45 kg/m2 per annum may be a potential strategy for safe rice production in Pb-As-contaminated fields.