How Robust are the Estimated Effects of Nonpharmaceutical Interventions against COVID-19?

被引：0
|
作者：
Sharma, Mrinank [1 ,2 ]
Mindermann, Soren
Brauner, Jan M. [3 ]
Leech, Gavin [4 ]
Stephenson, Anna B. [5 ]
Gavenciak, Tomas
Kulveit, Jan [6 ]
Teh, Yee Whye [1 ]
Chindelevitch, Leonid [7 ,8 ]
Gal, Yarin [3 ]
机构：
[1] Univ Oxford, Dept Stat, Oxford, England
[2] Univ Oxford, Dept Engn Sci, Oxford, England
[3] Univ Oxford, Dept Comp Sci, OATML Grp, Oxford, England
[4] Univ Bristol, Dept Comp Sci, Bristol, England
[5] Harvard Univ, Sch Engn & Appl Sci, Cambridge, MA USA
[6] Univ Oxford, Future Human Inst, Oxford, England
[7] MRC Ctr Global Infect Dis Anal, London, England
[8] Imperial Coll London, Sch Publ Hlth, Abdul Latif Jameel Inst Dis & Emergency Analyt J, London, England
来源：
ADVANCES IN NEURAL INFORMATION PROCESSING SYSTEMS 33, NEURIPS 2020 | 2020年 / 33卷
基金：
英国医学研究理事会; 英国工程与自然科学研究理事会;
关键词：
D O I：
暂无
中图分类号：
TP18 [人工智能理论];
学科分类号：
081104 ; 0812 ; 0835 ; 1405 ;
摘要：
To what extent are effectiveness estimates of nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) against COVID-19 influenced by the assumptions our models make? To answer this question, we investigate 2 state-of-the-art NPI effectiveness models and propose 6 variants that make different structural assumptions. In particular, we investigate how well NPI effectiveness estimates generalise to unseen countries, and their sensitivity to unobserved factors. Models that account for noise in disease transmission compare favourably. We further evaluate how robust estimates are to different choices of epidemiological parameters and data. Focusing on models that assume transmission noise, we find that previously published results are remarkably robust across these variables. Finally, we mathematically ground the interpretation of NPI effectiveness estimates when certain common assumptions do not hold.
引用
收藏
页数：12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Synchronized nonpharmaceutical interventions for the control of COVID-19
    Bing Zhang
    Shiwen Liang
    Gang Wang
    Chi Zhang
    Cai Chen
    Min Zou
    Wei Shen
    Haoyu Long
    Daihai He
    Yuelong Shu
    Xiangjun Du
    Nonlinear Dynamics, 2021, 106 : 1477 - 1489
  • [2] Synchronized nonpharmaceutical interventions for the control of COVID-19
    Zhang, Bing
    Liang, Shiwen
    Wang, Gang
    Zhang, Chi
    Chen, Cai
    Zou, Min
    Shen, Wei
    Long, Haoyu
    He, Daihai
    Shu, Yuelong
    Du, Xiangjun
    NONLINEAR DYNAMICS, 2021, 106 (02) : 1477 - 1489
  • [3] HPV and Covid-19 Era: effects of nonpharmaceutical interventions on HPV transmission
    Luigi, Ronga
    Stefania, Stolfa
    Francesca, Indraccolo
    Federica, Romanelli
    Fiore, Bavaro Davide
    Annalisa, Saracino
    Francesco, Di Gennaro
    Eugenio, Milano
    Mandorino, Manuela
    Adriana, Mosca
    Eleonora, Sparapano
    Carmela, De Carlo
    Lucia, Nisi
    Enrica, Ranieri
    Michele, Mastria
    Maria Teresa, Montagna
    Raffaele, Del Prete
    PATHOGENS AND GLOBAL HEALTH, 2023, 117 (08) : 735 - 743
  • [4] Nonpharmaceutical interventions for tackling the COVID-19 epidemic in Brazil
    Garcia, Leila Posenato
    Duarte, Elisete
    EPIDEMIOLOGIA E SERVICOS DE SAUDE, 2020, 29 (02):
  • [5] Nonpharmaceutical interventions against the COVID-19 pandemic significantly decreased the spread of enterovirus in children
    Zhang, Junfeng
    Cao, JiaJia
    Ye, Qing
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2022, 94 (08) : 3581 - 3588
  • [6] Effect Of Nonpharmaceutical Interventions On COVID-19 Cases And Deaths In Brazil
    Russell, Louise B.
    Santos da Silva, Lara Livia
    de Moraes, Rodrigo Fracalossi
    Gidwani, Risha
    Luz, Paula M.
    Toscano, Cristiana M.
    HEALTH AFFAIRS, 2022, 41 (07) : 1005 - 1012
  • [7] Nonpharmaceutical interventions in Turkey and worldwide during COVID-19 pandemic
    Ilhan, Mustafa Necmi
    Tuzun, Hakan
    Kilic, Rahmi
    Yildirim, Nuran
    TURKISH JOURNAL OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, 2021, 51 : 3207 - 3214
  • [8] Modeling COVID-19 Dynamics in Illinois under Nonpharmaceutical Interventions
    Wong, George N.
    Weiner, Zachary J.
    Tkachenko, Alexei, V
    Elbanna, Ahmed
    Maslov, Sergei
    Goldenfeld, Nigel
    PHYSICAL REVIEW X, 2020, 10 (04)
  • [9] Measures to cope with the COVID-19 pandemic in Germany: nonpharmaceutical and pharmaceutical interventions
    Grote, Ulrike
    Arvand, Mardjan
    Brinkwirth, Simon
    Brunke, Melanie
    Buchholz, Udo
    Eckmanns, Tim
    von Kleist, Max
    Niebank, Michaela
    Ruehe, Bettina
    Schulze, Kai
    Stoliaroff-Pepin, Anna
    Thanheiser, Marc
    Schaade, Lars
    Said, Dunja
    Haas, Walter
    BUNDESGESUNDHEITSBLATT-GESUNDHEITSFORSCHUNG-GESUNDHEITSSCHUTZ, 2021, 64 (04) : 435 - 445
  • [10] Climate-dependent effectiveness of nonpharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 mitigation
    Ji, Juping
    Wang, Hao
    Wang, Lin
    Ramazi, Pouria
    Kong, Jude Dzevela
    Watmough, James
    MATHEMATICAL BIOSCIENCES, 2023, 366
12345