A new method for quantifying redistribution of seabirds within operational offshore wind farms finds no evidence of within-wind farm displacement

被引:0
|
作者
Trinder, Mark [1 ]
O'Brien, Susan H. [1 ]
Deimel, Joseph [2 ]
机构
[1] MacArthur Green, Glasgow, Scotland
[2] Scottish & Southern Elect SSE Renewables Ltd, Perth, Scotland
关键词
displacement; meso-avoidance; environmental impact assessment; monitoring; seabirds; IMPACTS;
D O I
10.3389/fmars.2024.1235061
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
The climate crisis is driving a rapid increase in size and number of offshore wind farms to reduce carbon emissions from electricity generation. However, there are concerns about the potential impact of offshore wind farms on the marine environment. Seabirds are considered to be at risk of being displaced from preferred foraging habitat, by construction and operation of offshore wind farms, resulting in reduced energy intake or elevated energetic costs and consequent decreases in survival and/or productivity. Typically, displacement or avoidance behaviour is assessed by comparing abundance and spatial distributions of seabirds before and after an offshore wind farm is constructed. However, seabird distributions are highly variable through time and space and so discerning a change in distribution caused by an offshore wind farm from other environmental variables can be challenging. We present a new method that controls for temporal variation by examining the location of individual seabirds relative to turbines. Mean seabird density at different distances from individual turbines (0-400m) was calculated from data collected on a total of 12 digital aerial surveys of the Beatrice Offshore Wind Farm (UK), in May-August in 2019 and 2021. Mean densities of common guillemot (Uria aalge), razorbill (Alca torda), Atlantic puffin (Fratercula arctica) and black-legged kittiwake (Rissa tridactyla), both flying and sat on the water, were calculated. If the presence of turbines had no effect on seabird distribution, there should be no relationship between distance from turbine and seabird density. This was tested by simulating a relocation of turbines, relative to seabird distribution, and recalculating seabird density over 0-400m from simulated turbine locations. This was repeated to generate a bootstrapped distribution of expected densities against which observed density was compared. If displacement was occurring, mean observed density close to turbines would be significantly lower than expected density, derived from the bootstrap distribution. Overall, observed mean density did not differ significantly from expected density, i.e. no displacement effect was detected. There was a slight tendency for guillemot and razorbill, when sat on the water, to be at higher densities than expected, near turbines, suggestive of possible attraction to turbines, and for flying birds to be at lower densities than expected, near turbines, suggestive of possible avoidance. No flying razorbills were recorded within 100m of turbines but sample sizes were small. Kittiwake tended to show no avoidance or attraction behaviour, although flying kittiwake density was slightly lower than expected at 200m from turbines. Puffins sat on the water were recorded in densities similar to the expected density. Overall, no effect of turbine rotor speed was found, i.e. birds were not more likely to be displaced/avoid turbines at higher or lower rotor speeds. The results of the turbine relocation analysis gave a more consistent and more easily interpreted assessment of displacement/avoidance behaviour than the typical approaches of comparing abundance and seabird distribution through time. We strongly encourage application of this new approach to post-construction spatial distribution data from other offshore wind farms, to build the evidence base on the effects of offshore wind farms on seabirds.
引用
收藏
页数:16
相关论文
共 41 条
  • [1] Displacement of seabirds by an offshore wind farm in the North Sea
    Welcker, Jorg
    Nehls, Georg
    MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES, 2016, 554 : 173 - 182
  • [2] The Assessment of Overvoltage protection Within Energization of Offshore Wind Farms
    Soloot, Amir Hayati
    Hoidalen, Hans Kristian
    Gustavsen, Bjorn
    SELECTED PAPERS FROM DEEP SEA OFFSHORE WIND R&D CONFERENCE, 2012, 24 : 151 - 158
  • [3] Modelling turbulence intensity within a large offshore wind farm
    Argyle, Peter
    Watson, Simon
    Montavon, Christiane
    Jones, Ian
    Smith, Megan
    WIND ENERGY, 2018, 21 (12) : 1329 - 1343
  • [4] Approaching population thresholds in presence of uncertainty: Assessing displacement of seabirds from offshore wind farms
    Busch, Malte
    Garthe, Stefan
    ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW, 2016, 56 : 31 - 42
  • [5] Point-to-Point Channel Modelling Within Offshore Wind Farms
    Mbogo, Joseph
    Peng, Xiao-Hong
    Tang, Zuoyin
    THIRD INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS ON INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY, 2019, 797 : 201 - 210
  • [6] The impact of stable atmospheric boundary layers on wind-turbine wakes within offshore wind farms
    Doerenkaemper, Martin
    Witha, Bjoern
    Steinfeld, Gerald
    Heinemann, Detlev
    Kuehn, Martin
    JOURNAL OF WIND ENGINEERING AND INDUSTRIAL AERODYNAMICS, 2015, 144 : 146 - 153
  • [7] A Review and Analysis of the Uncertainty Within Cost Models for Floating Offshore Wind Farms
    Sykes, V.
    Collu, M.
    Coraddu, A.
    RENEWABLE & SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REVIEWS, 2023, 186
  • [8] A wind of change for soft-sediment infauna within operational offshore windfarms
    Lefaible, Nene
    Braeckman, Ulrike
    Degraer, Steven
    Vanaverbeke, Jan
    Moens, Tom
    MARINE ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH, 2023, 188
  • [9] Modeling turbine wakes and power losses within a wind farm using LES: An application to the Horns Rev offshore wind farm
    Wu, Yu-Ting
    Porte-Agel, Fernando
    RENEWABLE ENERGY, 2015, 75 : 945 - 955
  • [10] Wind Speed Estimation and Parametrization of Wake Models for Downregulated Offshore Wind Farms within the scope of PossPOW Project
    Bozkurt, Tuhfe Gocmen
    Giebel, Gregor
    Poulsen, Niels Kjolstad
    Mirzaei, Mahmood
    SCIENCE OF MAKING TORQUE FROM WIND 2014 (TORQUE 2014), 2014, 524