HEALTH-INSURANCE VALUES AND IMPLEMENTATION IN THE NETHERLANDS AND THE FEDERAL-REPUBLIC-OF-GERMANY - AN ALTERNATIVE PATH TO UNIVERSAL COVERAGE

The health care systems in the Netherlands and the Federal Republic of Germany are based on a set of values that involve mutual obligations between private parties. These obligations are realized through systems incorporating private practice physicians, community and church- and municipality-affiliated hospitals, and nonprofit and for-profit insurers. The underlying values and implementation approaches in these systems provide an alternative to the adoption of a Canadian-style health insurance system. A discussion that focuses on "obligations" rather than "rights" may be a more useful approach for the design of reforms of the American health system in the 1990s. Such a discussion would focus on the mutual responsibility of all parties to create and maintain a universal private health care system.