Minimum pricing for alcohol: a Millian perspective

被引:6
|
作者
Saunders, Ben [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Stirling, Philosophy, Stirling, Scotland
关键词
alcohol; pricing; liberalism; J.S; Mill; legitimacy; Scotland;
D O I
10.1080/21582041.2012.745589
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
The Scottish National Party (SNP) has recently sought to introduce minimum pricing for alcohol in order to tackle drink-related problems. This paper outlines what the prominent nineteenth-century liberal reformer John Stuart Mill would have said about such a proposal. Mill's 1859 On Liberty argued that the only legitimate reason for the state or society to interfere in an individual's conduct is to prevent harm to others, rejecting paternalistic interventions or moralistic legislation. After outlining Mill's general position, this paper gathers a number of his scattered remarks on alcohol. It seems that he would be prepared to endorse a number of restrictions on the sale of alcohol, including age restrictions, mandatory health warnings and even anti-social behaviour orders for those guilty of violent crime when drunk. Nonetheless, Mill is clear that the state has no right to prohibit alcohol and, for the same reasons, that the state has no right to increase its cost for purpose of deterring drinking - a measure that, Mill argues, differs only in degree from outright prohibition. Thus, according to Mill, the proposal of the SNP oversteps the bounds of legitimate government interference, unjustly interfering in individual liberty. Interestingly, however, Mill allows that governments have the right to tax inessential goods for purposes of raising revenue, which suggests that the government could legitimately tax alcohol, provided its reasoning was not (as the SNP has stressed its is) to deter people from drinking.
引用
收藏
页码:71 / 82
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] MINIMUM UNIT PRICING FOR ALCOHOL Support for minimum unit pricing for alcohol in the alcohol industry
    Rice, Peter
    [J]. BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2014, 349
  • [2] Regulating drinking through alcohol taxation and minimum unit pricing: A historical perspective on alcohol pricing interventions
    Yeomans, Henry
    [J]. REGULATION & GOVERNANCE, 2019, 13 (01) : 3 - 17
  • [3] MINIMUM PRICING OF ALCOHOL
    Ludbrook, Anne
    [J]. HEALTH ECONOMICS, 2009, 18 (12) : 1357 - 1360
  • [4] Minimum alcohol pricing in Scotland
    Roberts, Tom
    [J]. SAFER COMMUNITIES, 2011, 10 (01) : 16 - 19
  • [5] THE ECONOMICS OF MINIMUM PRICING FOR ALCOHOL
    Craven, Barrie
    Marlow, Michael
    Shiers, Alden
    [J]. ECONOMIC AFFAIRS, 2013, 33 (02) : 174 - 189
  • [6] Minimum alcohol pricing in Scotland
    不详
    [J]. LANCET GASTROENTEROLOGY & HEPATOLOGY, 2018, 3 (01): : 1 - 1
  • [7] MINIMUM UNIT PRICING AND SALES OF ALCOHOL IN SCOTLAND Minimum unit alcohol pricing in Scotland: Is England next?
    Graham, Christopher J.
    [J]. BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2023, 380
  • [8] Minimum unit pricing for alcohol in Scotland
    Mooney, John D.
    Carlin, Eric
    [J]. BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2019, 366
  • [9] MINIMUM ALCOHOL PRICING IN ENGLAND AND WALES What is convincing evidence on alcohol pricing?
    Robinson, Mark
    McCartney, Gerry
    Beeston, Clare
    [J]. BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2013, 347
  • [10] The role of the Sheffield model on the minimum unit pricing of alcohol debate: the importance of a rhetorical perspective
    Katikireddi, Srinivasa Vittal
    Hilton, Shona
    Bond, Lyndal
    [J]. EVIDENCE & POLICY, 2016, 12 (04): : 521 - 539